|
Æóðíàë çàðóáåæíîãî çàêîíîäàòåëüñòâà è ñðàâíèòåëüíîãî ïðàâîâåäåíèÿ / Journal of foreighn legislation and comparative law
Ïðàâèëüíàÿ ññûëêà íà ñòàòüþ:
Ä.ß. Ïðèìàêîâ
Ðàçâèòèå óãîëîâíîãî çàêîíîäàòåëüñòâà Èçðàèëÿ (1936–1977)
// Æóðíàë çàðóáåæíîãî çàêîíîäàòåëüñòâà è ñðàâíèòåëüíîãî ïðàâîâåäåíèÿ / Journal of foreighn legislation and comparative law.
2011. ¹ 5.
Ñ. 93-104.
URL: https://nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=58925
Ä.ß. Ïðèìàêîâ Ðàçâèòèå óãîëîâíîãî çàêîíîäàòåëüñòâà Èçðàèëÿ (1936–1977)
Àííîòàöèÿ:
 äàííîé ñòàòüå ðàññìàòðèâàþòñÿ âîïðîñû ðàçâèòèÿ óãîëîâíîãî çàêîíîäàòåëüñòâà Èçðàèëÿ â XX â. è âëèÿíèÿ íà åãî ñòàíîâëåíèå àíãëèéñêîé ïðàâîâîé äîêòðèíû. Òàêæå â ðàáîòå âûäåëÿþòñÿ ðÿä îñîáåííîñòåé óãîëîâíîãî èçðàèëüñêîãî çàêîíîäàòåëüñòâà, îòðàæåííûå â íîðìàõ äâóõ îñíîâíûõ çàêîíàõ: â Îðäîíàíñå îá óãîëîâíîì ïðàâå 1936 ã. è â Çàêîíå îá óãîëîâíîì ïðàâå 1977 ã. Àâòîð ïðèõîäèò ê âûâîäó, ÷òî óãîëîâíîå çàêîíîäàòåëüñòâî Èçðàèëÿ (êàê 1936, òàê è 1977 ãîäîâ) çàíèìàåò îñîáîå ìåñòî: â íåì îò÷åòëèâî âèäíî âëèÿíèå îáùåãî ïðàâà, îäíàêî îíî êîäèôèöèðîâàíî (â îòëè÷èå îò ñàìîé Àíãëèè è ÑØÀ), ê òîìó æå â íåì íàøëè îòðàæåíèÿ îñîáåííîñòè ãîñóäàðñòâåííîãî è îáùåñòâåííîãî óñòðîéñòâà ãîñóäàðñòâà.
Êëþ÷åâûå ñëîâà:
èçðàèëüñêîå óãîëîâíîå ïðàâî, âëèÿíèå àíãëèéñêîãî ïðàâà, Îðäîíàíñ 1936, óãîëîâíàÿ îòâåòñòâåííîñòü þðèäè÷åñêèõ ëèö.
Abstract: In this article scrutinize an issue of the penal law evaluation in Israel. The essential influence took place from
the British legality and common law doctrine. However the Criminal Law Ordinance 1936 and Criminal Law Act 1977
show authentic place which the Israel Modern Criminal Law takes plays.
Keywords: Israel Criminal Law, influence, legal transplants, common law doctrine.
Áèáëèîãðàôèÿ
1. Mishpat hukati / mehadura meuhedet le–studentim. Ierushalaim, 2006.
2. Seder din Ezrahi u–batei–mishpat. Sefer hakika / mehadura meuhedet le–studentim. Ierushalaim, 2007.
3. Hok Onshin. Sefer hakika. /mehadura meuhedet le–studentim. Ierushalaim, 2009.
4. Çàêîí îá óãîëîâíîì ïðàâå Èçðàèëÿ / ïðåäèñë., ïåð. ñ èâðèòà Ì. Äîðôìàí. ÑÏá., 2005. Ëèòåðàòóðà íà ðóññêîì ÿçûêå: 1. Àøà Àí–Íàèì. Íà ïóòè ê èñëàìñêîé ðåôîðìàöèè. Ì., 1992. 2. Áàðàê À. Ñóäåéñêîå óñìîòðåíèå. Ì., 1999. 3. Âîðîáüåâ Â.ï. Ãîñóäàðñòâî Èçðàèëü: ïðàâîâûå îñíîâû âîçíèêíîâåíèÿ è ñòàòóñ ëè÷íîñòè. Ì., 2001. 4. Äîäîíîâ Â.Í. Ñðàâíèòåëüíîå óãîëîâíîå ïðàâî. Ì., 2009.
5. Åñàêîâ Ã.À. Ñîó÷àñòèå ïî àíãëèéñêîìó óãîëîâíîìó ïðàâó // Ðîññèéñêèé åæåãîäíèê óãîëîâíîãî ïðàâà. 2006. ¹ 1.
6. Êàáðèÿê Ð. Êîäèôèêàöèè. Ì., 2007.
7. „K„p„„y„~„…„ƒ „O.„R. „R„?„r„‚„u„}„u„~„~„?„u „…„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„? „r „Q„?„ƒ„ƒ„y„y „y „x„p „‚„…„q„u„w„?„}: „~„u„{„?„„„?„‚„„u „„‚„?„q„|„u„}„ „?„„„r„u„„„ƒ„„„r„u„~„~„?„ƒ„„„y. „M., 2008.
8. „K„u„~„y „K. „O„ƒ„~„?„r„ „…„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p. „M., 1949.
9. „M„p„‚„‰„u„~„{„? „M. „N. „K„…„‚„ƒ „ƒ„‚„p„r„~„y„„„u„|„Ž„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„‘. „M., 2002.
10. „M„u„t„…„Š„u„r„ƒ„{„y„z „@. „K„u„|„Ž„x„u„~„?„r„ƒ„{„p„‘ „}„?„t„u„|„Ž „{„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„?„~„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„?„ƒ„…„t„y„‘ „y „y„x„}„u„~„u„~„y„‘ „{„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„z „r „ƒ„„„‚„p„~„p„‡ „B„?„ƒ„„„?„‰„~„?„z „E„r„‚„?„„ // „K„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„?„~„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„?„ƒ„…„t„y„u „r „„?„ƒ„„„{„?„}„}„…„~„y„ƒ„„„y„‰„u„ƒ„{„y„‡ „ƒ„„„‚„p„~„p„‡: „R„q„?„‚„~„y„{ „t„?„{„|„p„t„?„r. „M., 1999.
11. „P„‚„y„}„p„{„?„r „D.„`. „O„ƒ„?„q„u„~„~„?„ƒ„„„y „u„r„‚„u„z„ƒ„{„?„z „„‚„p„r„?„r„?„z „ƒ„y„ƒ„„„u„}„ „~„p „„‚„y„}„u„‚„u „ƒ„‚„p„r„~„u„~„y„‘ „u„r„‚„u„z„ƒ„{„?„s„? „y „}„…„ƒ„…„|„Ž„}„p„~-„ƒ„{„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p // „B„u„ƒ„„„~„y„{ „R„p„~„{„„.„P„u„„„u„‚„q„…„‚„s„ƒ„{„?„s„? „…„~„y„r„u„‚„ƒ„y„„„u„„„p. 2010. „M„p„‚„„. „R„u„‚„y„‘ 14 á„P„‚„p„r„?â.
12. „P„‚„y„}„p„{„?„r „D.„`. „P„‚„y„}„u„~„u„~„y„u „„‚„y„~„ˆ„y„„p „Š„p„‚„y„p„„„p „r „{„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„?„~„~„?„} „x„p„{„?„~„?„t„p„„„u„|„Ž„ƒ„„„r„u „E„s„y„„„„p // „G„…„‚„~„p„| „x„p-„‚„…„q„u„w„~„?„s„? „x„p„{„?„~„?„t„p„„„u„|„Ž„ƒ„„„r„p „y „ƒ„‚„p„r„~„y„„„u„|„Ž„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„‘. 2008 ‡‚ 4.
13. „P„‚„y„}„p„{„?„r „D.„`. „R„u„}„u„z„~„?„u „x„p„{„?„~„?„t„p„„„u„|„Ž„ƒ„„„r„? „E„s„y„„„„p „r XX „r. „y „r„|„y„‘„~„y„u „x„p„„p„t„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p // „I„t„u„p„|„. „W„u„~„~„?„ƒ„„„y. „N„?„‚„}„: VI „}„u„w„t„…„~„p„‚„?„t„~„p„‘ „~„p„…„‰„~„p„‘ „{„?„~„†„u„‚„u„~„ˆ„y„‘ „„? „r„?„ƒ„„„?„{„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„ („S„?„‚„‰„y„~„?„r„ƒ„{„y„u „‰„„„u„~„y„‘). 3.6 „†„u„r„‚„p„|„‘ 2010 „s. / „ƒ„?„ƒ„„. „y „?„„„r. „‚„u„t. „R.„B. „P„p„‡„?„}„?„r. „R„P„q., 2010.
14. „P„‚„y„}„p„{„?„r „D.„`. „R„y„ƒ„„„u„}„p„„„y„x„p„ˆ„y„‘ „s„‚„p„w„t„p„~„ƒ„{„?„s„? „x„p„{„?„~„?„t„p„„„u„|„Ž„ƒ„„„r„p „E„s„y„„„„p („{„?„~„u„ˆ XIX . „ƒ„u„‚„u„t„y„~„p XX „r.) // „P„‚„p„r„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„u. 2008. ‡‚ 5.
15. „R„p„y„t „^.„B. „O„‚„y„u„~„„„p„|„y„x„}. „H„p„„p„t„~„„u „{„?„~„ˆ„u„„ˆ„y„y „B„?„ƒ„„„?„{„p. „R„P„q., 2006.
16. „R„p„{„u„‚„p „C. „I„ƒ„„„?„‚„y„‘ „I„x„‚„p„y„|„‘. „O„„ „B„?„z„~„ „x„p „~„u„x„p„r„y„ƒ„y„}„?„ƒ„„„Ž „t„? „Y„u„ƒ„„„y„t„~„u„r„~„?„z „r„?„z„~„. „I„u„‚„…„ƒ„p„|„y„}, 1995.
17. „R„p„„‚„?„~„?„r„p „M.„@. „C„?„ƒ„…„t„p„‚„ƒ„„„r„u„~„~„„z „ƒ„„„‚„?„z „y „{„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„y „p„‚„p„q„ƒ„{„y„‡ „‚„u„ƒ„„…„q„|„y„{. „M., 2003.
18. „T„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„? „x„p„‚„…„q„u„w„~„„‡ „ƒ„„„‚„p„~. „O„q„‹„p„‘ „y „?„ƒ„?„q„u„~„~„p„‘ „‰„p„ƒ„„„y / „„?„t „‚„u„t. „I.„D. „K„?„x„?„‰„{„y„~„p. „M., 2010.
19. „T„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„? „x„p„‚„…„q„u„w„~„„‡ „ƒ„„„‚„p„~. „O„q„‹„p„‘ „‰„p„ƒ„„„Ž / „„?„t „‚„u„t. „I.„D. „K„?„x„?„‰„{„y„~„p. „M., 2003.
20. „T„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„?. „O„q„‹„p„‘ „‰„p„ƒ„„„Ž. „T„‰„u„q„~„y„{. / „„?„t „‚„u„t. „N.„M. „K„‚„?„„p„‰„u„r„p, „A.„B. „B„?„|„w„u„~„{„y„~„p, „B.„B. „O„‚„u„‡„?„r„p. „R„P„q., 2006.
21. „U„p„z„‚„ƒ„„„?„…„~ „S. „T„s„?„|„?„r„~„p„‘ „?„„„r„u„„„ƒ„„„r„u„~„~„?„ƒ„„„Ž „„‚„y„t„y„‰„u„ƒ„{„y„‡ „|„y„ˆ „r „R„Y„@ // „Q„?„ƒ„ƒ„y„z„ƒ„{„y„z „u„w„u„s„?„t„~„y„{ „…„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p. 2007. ‡‚ 2. „R. 597.609.
22. „V„p„~„s„„„y„~„s„„„?„~ C. „R„„„?„|„{„~„?„r„u„~„y„‘ „W„y„r„y„|„y„x„p„ˆ„y„z. „M., 2003.
23. „W„r„p„z„s„u„‚„„ „K., „Ke„„„ˆ „V. „B„r„u„t„u„~„y„u „r „ƒ„‚„p„r„~„y„„„u„|„Ž„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„u „r „ƒ„†„u„‚„u „‰„p„ƒ„„„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p: „B 2.„‡ „„„„. „M., 1995. „L„y„„„u„‚„p„„„…„‚„p „~„p „p„~„s„|„y„z„ƒ„{„?„} „‘„x„„{„u: 1. Bach G. Development of Criminal Law in Israel during the 25 Years of its Existence // Israel Law Review. Vol. 9. 1974. ‡‚ 4. 2. Baker H. E. Legal System of Israel. Jerusalem, 1968. 3. Barak A. Human Rights in Israel // Israel Law Review Vol. 39. 1997. ‡‚ 2. 4. Barak A. The Constitutionalization of the Israeli Legal System as a Result of the Basic Laws and its Effect on Procedural and Substantive Criminal Law // Israel Law Review Vol. 31. 1997. ‡‚ 1. 5. Beckstrom H.J. Transplantation of Legal System: An Early Report on the Reception of Western Laws in Ethiopia // The American Journal of Comparative Law. Vol. 21. 1973, Summer. ‡‚ 3. 6. Bein D. Recent Developments in Israel Criminal Law // 1977. ‡‚ 12. 7. Benwich N. The Criminal Code of Palestine // Law Journal. 1937. ‡‚ 83. 8. Benwich N. The legal Administration of Palestine under the British Military Occupation 1920.1921 // British Yearbook of International Law. 1921. ‡‚ 1. 9. Cruz P., de. A Modern Approach to Comparative law. Boston, 1993. 10. David R. Civil code for Ethiopia // Tulane L.R. 1967. ‡‚ 37. 11. David R. Sources of the Ethiopean Civil Code // J. Ethiopian Law. 1967/ ‡‚ 4. 12. Englard I. The Law of Torts in Israel: The Problems of Common Law Codification in a Mixed Legal System // American Journal of Comparative Law. 1974. ‡‚ 22. 13. Fridmann D. Infusion of the Common Law into the legal System of Israel // Israel Law Review. 1975. ‡‚ 10. 14. Fridmann D. The Effect of Foreign Law on the Law of Israel: Remnants of the Ottoman Period // Israel Law Review. 1975. ‡‚ 10. 15. Friedland M. L. R. S. Wrightfs Model Criminal Code: A Forgotten Chapter in the History of the Criminal Law // Oxford Journal of Legal Studies. 1981. ‡‚ 1. 16. Ginossar S. Israel Law: Components and Trends // Israel Law Review. 1966. ‡‚ 3. 17. Griffiths J. What is Legal Pluralism // J. of Legal Pluralism. 1986. ¹ 24. 18. Hammai K. (eds) Probation around the World. London, 1995. 19. Hassin Y. Raising Age of Criminal Responsibility in Israel // Israel Law Review. 1981. ¹ 16. 20. Kadish S.H. Codifiers of the Criminal Law: Wechsler’s Predecessors // Columbia Law Review. 1978. ¹ 78. 21. Keppel G. The Revenge of God: the Resurgence of Islam, Christianity and Judaism in the Modern World. Pennsylvania, 1994. 22. Klein C. La democratie d’Israël. Paris, 1997. 23. Klein Ñ. French Administrative Law as a Paradigm: Some remarks concerning its Use by the Supreme Court of Israel // Tel–Aviv University Studies L. 1992. ¹ 11.
24. Krislov S. The amicus curiae brief: from Friendship to Advocacy // The Yale Law Journal. Vol. 72. 1963, Mar. N 4.
25. Liebesny H.J. The Law of the Near and Middle East. Albany (NY), 1975.
26. Likhovsky A. The Time has not Yet come to Repair the World in the Kingdom of God: Israeli Lawyers and the Failed Jewish Legal Revolution of 1948 // Tel–Aviv University Law School. Year 2008, paper 68.
27. Likhovsky A. Law and Identity in Mandate Palestine. Northern Carolina, 2006.
28. Likhovsy A. In Our Image: Colonial Discourse and the Anglicization of the Law of Mandatory Palestine // Israel Law Review. Vol. 29. 1995. ¹ 3.
29. Lombardi Ñ. Islamic Law as a source of Constitutional Law in Egypt: the Constituotionalization of the Sharia in Modern Arab State // Columbia Journal of Transnational Law. 1989. ¹ 37.
30. O’Regan R. S. Sir Samuel Griffith’s Criminal Code // Royal Historical Society of Queensland Journal. Vol. XIV. 1991, August. ¹ 8.
31. Sebba L. Sanctioning Policy in Israel — an Historical Overview // Israel Law Review. Vol. 30. 1996, summer– autumn. ¹ 3–4
32. Sebba L. The Creation and Evolution of Criminal Law in Colonial and Post–Colonial Societies // Crime, History, Society. Vol. 3. 1999. ¹ 1.
33. Shalgi M. The New Code of Criminal Procedure in Israel // Israel Law Review. 1966. ¹ 1.
34. Sheleff L. When a minority becomes a majority — Jewish Law and Tradition in the State of Israel // The Tel–Aviv University Studies in Law. 1997. Vol. 13.
35. Silberg M. Talmudic Law and the Modern State. Oxford, 1973.
36. Yadin U. From Piecemeal Legislation to a Modern Code, The Israeli Experience // Memoriam Uri Yadin. Vol. II. Jerusalem, 1990.
37. Zegal M. Religion and Politics in Egypt: The Ulema of Al–Azhar, Radical Islam and the State // International Journal of Middle East Studies. 1999. ¹ 31.
38. Zerubavel Y. Recovered Roots: Collective Memory and the Making of National Tradition. Chicago, 1995. Ëèòåðàòóðà íà èâðèòå: 1. Barak–Erez D. Mispatei miftah: zhiunei dereh ba–betei ha–mishpat ha–elion. Israel, 2003. 2. Cohen H. Lihiet iehudi: masoret, din, dat ve–medina. Ierushalaim, 2006. 3. Cohen H. Mishpat. Ierushalaim, 2006. 4. Fridman Sh., Radziner A. Huka she–lo ktuva ba–Tora. Ierushalayim, 2006. 5. Gavinzon R. Bitul Medgela — minhag ve ekronot ha–afiha // Mishpatim. 1986. ¹ 14. 6. Haris R. Shimur Masoret Mishpatiet be–hevrot Post–kolaniet // Ierushalaim be–Tkufat Mandat (or. Ehashua ben– Arie). 7. Harris R., Likhovskey A., Kadar A. Bein Mishpat le–Historia: al ha–Istoriografia shel ha–Mishpat ha–Israeli // Iunei Mishpat. 2002, Nov. 8. Hirsch J. Mahpeha be–Galaha. Jerushalaim, 2002. 9. Likhovski A. Bein mandat le–medina: al halukat ha–historia shel ha–mishpat ha–israeli le–tkufot // Mishpatim. 1997. ¹ 27. 10. Rubenstein A. Shoftei–Eretz: Le–Rishoto ve–le–Dmuto shel Beit Mishpat Ha–Elion ba–Israel. Tel–Aviv, 1988. 11. Rubenstein A., Medina B. Ha–Mishpat ha–Konstitutzioni shel Medinat Israel. Mehadura hamishit, 1995. 12. Zilberg M. Kah Darko shel Talmud. Ierushalaim, 1969
References
1. Mishpat hukati / mehadura meuhedet le–studentim. Ierushalaim, 2006.
2. Seder din Ezrahi u–batei–mishpat. Sefer hakika / mehadura meuhedet le–studentim. Ierushalaim, 2007.
3. Hok Onshin. Sefer hakika. /mehadura meuhedet le–studentim. Ierushalaim, 2009.
4. Zakon ob ugolovnom prave Izrailya / predisl., per. s ivrita M. Dorfman. SPb., 2005. Literatura na russkom yazyke: 1. Asha An–Naim. Na puti k islamskoi reformatsii. M., 1992. 2. Barak A. Sudeiskoe usmotrenie. M., 1999. 3. Vorob'ev V.p. Gosudarstvo Izrail': pravovye osnovy vozniknoveniya i status lichnosti. M., 2001. 4. Dodonov V.N. Sravnitel'noe ugolovnoe pravo. M., 2009.
5. Esakov G.A. Souchastie po angliiskomu ugolovnomu pravu // Rossiiskii ezhegodnik ugolovnogo prava. 2006. ¹ 1.
6. Kabriyak R. Kodifikatsii. M., 2007.
7. „K„p„„y„~„…„ƒ „O.„R. „R„?„r„‚„u„}„u„~„~„?„u „…„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„? „r „Q„?„ƒ„ƒ„y„y „y „x„p „‚„…„q„u„w„?„}: „~„u„{„?„„„?„‚„„u „„‚„?„q„|„u„}„ „?„„„r„u„„„ƒ„„„r„u„~„~„?„ƒ„„„y. „M., 2008.
8. „K„u„~„y „K. „O„ƒ„~„?„r„ „…„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p. „M., 1949.
9. „M„p„‚„‰„u„~„{„? „M. „N. „K„…„‚„ƒ „ƒ„‚„p„r„~„y„„„u„|„Ž„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„‘. „M., 2002.
10. „M„u„t„…„Š„u„r„ƒ„{„y„z „@. „K„u„|„Ž„x„u„~„?„r„ƒ„{„p„‘ „}„?„t„u„|„Ž „{„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„?„~„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„?„ƒ„…„t„y„‘ „y „y„x„}„u„~„u„~„y„‘ „{„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„z „r „ƒ„„„‚„p„~„p„‡ „B„?„ƒ„„„?„‰„~„?„z „E„r„‚„?„„ // „K„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„?„~„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„?„ƒ„…„t„y„u „r „„?„ƒ„„„{„?„}„}„…„~„y„ƒ„„„y„‰„u„ƒ„{„y„‡ „ƒ„„„‚„p„~„p„‡: „R„q„?„‚„~„y„{ „t„?„{„|„p„t„?„r. „M., 1999.
11. „P„‚„y„}„p„{„?„r „D.„`. „O„ƒ„?„q„u„~„~„?„ƒ„„„y „u„r„‚„u„z„ƒ„{„?„z „„‚„p„r„?„r„?„z „ƒ„y„ƒ„„„u„}„ „~„p „„‚„y„}„u„‚„u „ƒ„‚„p„r„~„u„~„y„‘ „u„r„‚„u„z„ƒ„{„?„s„? „y „}„…„ƒ„…„|„Ž„}„p„~-„ƒ„{„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p // „B„u„ƒ„„„~„y„{ „R„p„~„{„„.„P„u„„„u„‚„q„…„‚„s„ƒ„{„?„s„? „…„~„y„r„u„‚„ƒ„y„„„u„„„p. 2010. „M„p„‚„„. „R„u„‚„y„‘ 14 á„P„‚„p„r„?â.
12. „P„‚„y„}„p„{„?„r „D.„`. „P„‚„y„}„u„~„u„~„y„u „„‚„y„~„ˆ„y„„p „Š„p„‚„y„p„„„p „r „{„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„?„~„~„?„} „x„p„{„?„~„?„t„p„„„u„|„Ž„ƒ„„„r„u „E„s„y„„„„p // „G„…„‚„~„p„| „x„p-„‚„…„q„u„w„~„?„s„? „x„p„{„?„~„?„t„p„„„u„|„Ž„ƒ„„„r„p „y „ƒ„‚„p„r„~„y„„„u„|„Ž„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„‘. 2008 ‡‚ 4.
13. „P„‚„y„}„p„{„?„r „D.„`. „R„u„}„u„z„~„?„u „x„p„{„?„~„?„t„p„„„u„|„Ž„ƒ„„„r„? „E„s„y„„„„p „r XX „r. „y „r„|„y„‘„~„y„u „x„p„„p„t„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p // „I„t„u„p„|„. „W„u„~„~„?„ƒ„„„y. „N„?„‚„}„: VI „}„u„w„t„…„~„p„‚„?„t„~„p„‘ „~„p„…„‰„~„p„‘ „{„?„~„†„u„‚„u„~„ˆ„y„‘ „„? „r„?„ƒ„„„?„{„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„ („S„?„‚„‰„y„~„?„r„ƒ„{„y„u „‰„„„u„~„y„‘). 3.6 „†„u„r„‚„p„|„‘ 2010 „s. / „ƒ„?„ƒ„„. „y „?„„„r. „‚„u„t. „R.„B. „P„p„‡„?„}„?„r. „R„P„q., 2010.
14. „P„‚„y„}„p„{„?„r „D.„`. „R„y„ƒ„„„u„}„p„„„y„x„p„ˆ„y„‘ „s„‚„p„w„t„p„~„ƒ„{„?„s„? „x„p„{„?„~„?„t„p„„„u„|„Ž„ƒ„„„r„p „E„s„y„„„„p („{„?„~„u„ˆ XIX . „ƒ„u„‚„u„t„y„~„p XX „r.) // „P„‚„p„r„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„u. 2008. ‡‚ 5.
15. „R„p„y„t „^.„B. „O„‚„y„u„~„„„p„|„y„x„}. „H„p„„p„t„~„„u „{„?„~„ˆ„u„„ˆ„y„y „B„?„ƒ„„„?„{„p. „R„P„q., 2006.
16. „R„p„{„u„‚„p „C. „I„ƒ„„„?„‚„y„‘ „I„x„‚„p„y„|„‘. „O„„ „B„?„z„~„ „x„p „~„u„x„p„r„y„ƒ„y„}„?„ƒ„„„Ž „t„? „Y„u„ƒ„„„y„t„~„u„r„~„?„z „r„?„z„~„. „I„u„‚„…„ƒ„p„|„y„}, 1995.
17. „R„p„„‚„?„~„?„r„p „M.„@. „C„?„ƒ„…„t„p„‚„ƒ„„„r„u„~„~„„z „ƒ„„„‚„?„z „y „{„?„~„ƒ„„„y„„„…„ˆ„y„y „p„‚„p„q„ƒ„{„y„‡ „‚„u„ƒ„„…„q„|„y„{. „M., 2003.
18. „T„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„? „x„p„‚„…„q„u„w„~„„‡ „ƒ„„„‚„p„~. „O„q„‹„p„‘ „y „?„ƒ„?„q„u„~„~„p„‘ „‰„p„ƒ„„„y / „„?„t „‚„u„t. „I.„D. „K„?„x„?„‰„{„y„~„p. „M., 2010.
19. „T„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„? „x„p„‚„…„q„u„w„~„„‡ „ƒ„„„‚„p„~. „O„q„‹„p„‘ „‰„p„ƒ„„„Ž / „„?„t „‚„u„t. „I.„D. „K„?„x„?„‰„{„y„~„p. „M., 2003.
20. „T„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„?. „O„q„‹„p„‘ „‰„p„ƒ„„„Ž. „T„‰„u„q„~„y„{. / „„?„t „‚„u„t. „N.„M. „K„‚„?„„p„‰„u„r„p, „A.„B. „B„?„|„w„u„~„{„y„~„p, „B.„B. „O„‚„u„‡„?„r„p. „R„P„q., 2006.
21. „U„p„z„‚„ƒ„„„?„…„~ „S. „T„s„?„|„?„r„~„p„‘ „?„„„r„u„„„ƒ„„„r„u„~„~„?„ƒ„„„Ž „„‚„y„t„y„‰„u„ƒ„{„y„‡ „|„y„ˆ „r „R„Y„@ // „Q„?„ƒ„ƒ„y„z„ƒ„{„y„z „u„w„u„s„?„t„~„y„{ „…„s„?„|„?„r„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p. 2007. ‡‚ 2. „R. 597.609.
22. „V„p„~„s„„„y„~„s„„„?„~ C. „R„„„?„|„{„~„?„r„u„~„y„‘ „W„y„r„y„|„y„x„p„ˆ„y„z. „M., 2003.
23. „W„r„p„z„s„u„‚„„ „K., „Ke„„„ˆ „V. „B„r„u„t„u„~„y„u „r „ƒ„‚„p„r„~„y„„„u„|„Ž„~„?„u „„‚„p„r„?„r„u„t„u„~„y„u „r „ƒ„†„u„‚„u „‰„p„ƒ„„„~„?„s„? „„‚„p„r„p: „B 2.„‡ „„„„. „M., 1995. „L„y„„„u„‚„p„„„…„‚„p „~„p „p„~„s„|„y„z„ƒ„{„?„} „‘„x„„{„u: 1. Bach G. Development of Criminal Law in Israel during the 25 Years of its Existence // Israel Law Review. Vol. 9. 1974. ‡‚ 4. 2. Baker H. E. Legal System of Israel. Jerusalem, 1968. 3. Barak A. Human Rights in Israel // Israel Law Review Vol. 39. 1997. ‡‚ 2. 4. Barak A. The Constitutionalization of the Israeli Legal System as a Result of the Basic Laws and its Effect on Procedural and Substantive Criminal Law // Israel Law Review Vol. 31. 1997. ‡‚ 1. 5. Beckstrom H.J. Transplantation of Legal System: An Early Report on the Reception of Western Laws in Ethiopia // The American Journal of Comparative Law. Vol. 21. 1973, Summer. ‡‚ 3. 6. Bein D. Recent Developments in Israel Criminal Law // 1977. ‡‚ 12. 7. Benwich N. The Criminal Code of Palestine // Law Journal. 1937. ‡‚ 83. 8. Benwich N. The legal Administration of Palestine under the British Military Occupation 1920.1921 // British Yearbook of International Law. 1921. ‡‚ 1. 9. Cruz P., de. A Modern Approach to Comparative law. Boston, 1993. 10. David R. Civil code for Ethiopia // Tulane L.R. 1967. ‡‚ 37. 11. David R. Sources of the Ethiopean Civil Code // J. Ethiopian Law. 1967/ ‡‚ 4. 12. Englard I. The Law of Torts in Israel: The Problems of Common Law Codification in a Mixed Legal System // American Journal of Comparative Law. 1974. ‡‚ 22. 13. Fridmann D. Infusion of the Common Law into the legal System of Israel // Israel Law Review. 1975. ‡‚ 10. 14. Fridmann D. The Effect of Foreign Law on the Law of Israel: Remnants of the Ottoman Period // Israel Law Review. 1975. ‡‚ 10. 15. Friedland M. L. R. S. Wrightfs Model Criminal Code: A Forgotten Chapter in the History of the Criminal Law // Oxford Journal of Legal Studies. 1981. ‡‚ 1. 16. Ginossar S. Israel Law: Components and Trends // Israel Law Review. 1966. ‡‚ 3. 17. Griffiths J. What is Legal Pluralism // J. of Legal Pluralism. 1986. ¹ 24. 18. Hammai K. (eds) Probation around the World. London, 1995. 19. Hassin Y. Raising Age of Criminal Responsibility in Israel // Israel Law Review. 1981. ¹ 16. 20. Kadish S.H. Codifiers of the Criminal Law: Wechsler’s Predecessors // Columbia Law Review. 1978. ¹ 78. 21. Keppel G. The Revenge of God: the Resurgence of Islam, Christianity and Judaism in the Modern World. Pennsylvania, 1994. 22. Klein C. La democratie d’Israël. Paris, 1997. 23. Klein S. French Administrative Law as a Paradigm: Some remarks concerning its Use by the Supreme Court of Israel // Tel–Aviv University Studies L. 1992. ¹ 11.
24. Krislov S. The amicus curiae brief: from Friendship to Advocacy // The Yale Law Journal. Vol. 72. 1963, Mar. N 4.
25. Liebesny H.J. The Law of the Near and Middle East. Albany (NY), 1975.
26. Likhovsky A. The Time has not Yet come to Repair the World in the Kingdom of God: Israeli Lawyers and the Failed Jewish Legal Revolution of 1948 // Tel–Aviv University Law School. Year 2008, paper 68.
27. Likhovsky A. Law and Identity in Mandate Palestine. Northern Carolina, 2006.
28. Likhovsy A. In Our Image: Colonial Discourse and the Anglicization of the Law of Mandatory Palestine // Israel Law Review. Vol. 29. 1995. ¹ 3.
29. Lombardi S. Islamic Law as a source of Constitutional Law in Egypt: the Constituotionalization of the Sharia in Modern Arab State // Columbia Journal of Transnational Law. 1989. ¹ 37.
30. O’Regan R. S. Sir Samuel Griffith’s Criminal Code // Royal Historical Society of Queensland Journal. Vol. XIV. 1991, August. ¹ 8.
31. Sebba L. Sanctioning Policy in Israel — an Historical Overview // Israel Law Review. Vol. 30. 1996, summer– autumn. ¹ 3–4
32. Sebba L. The Creation and Evolution of Criminal Law in Colonial and Post–Colonial Societies // Crime, History, Society. Vol. 3. 1999. ¹ 1.
33. Shalgi M. The New Code of Criminal Procedure in Israel // Israel Law Review. 1966. ¹ 1.
34. Sheleff L. When a minority becomes a majority — Jewish Law and Tradition in the State of Israel // The Tel–Aviv University Studies in Law. 1997. Vol. 13.
35. Silberg M. Talmudic Law and the Modern State. Oxford, 1973.
36. Yadin U. From Piecemeal Legislation to a Modern Code, The Israeli Experience // Memoriam Uri Yadin. Vol. II. Jerusalem, 1990.
37. Zegal M. Religion and Politics in Egypt: The Ulema of Al–Azhar, Radical Islam and the State // International Journal of Middle East Studies. 1999. ¹ 31.
38. Zerubavel Y. Recovered Roots: Collective Memory and the Making of National Tradition. Chicago, 1995. Literatura na ivrite: 1. Barak–Erez D. Mispatei miftah: zhiunei dereh ba–betei ha–mishpat ha–elion. Israel, 2003. 2. Cohen H. Lihiet iehudi: masoret, din, dat ve–medina. Ierushalaim, 2006. 3. Cohen H. Mishpat. Ierushalaim, 2006. 4. Fridman Sh., Radziner A. Huka she–lo ktuva ba–Tora. Ierushalayim, 2006. 5. Gavinzon R. Bitul Medgela — minhag ve ekronot ha–afiha // Mishpatim. 1986. ¹ 14. 6. Haris R. Shimur Masoret Mishpatiet be–hevrot Post–kolaniet // Ierushalaim be–Tkufat Mandat (or. Ehashua ben– Arie). 7. Harris R., Likhovskey A., Kadar A. Bein Mishpat le–Historia: al ha–Istoriografia shel ha–Mishpat ha–Israeli // Iunei Mishpat. 2002, Nov. 8. Hirsch J. Mahpeha be–Galaha. Jerushalaim, 2002. 9. Likhovski A. Bein mandat le–medina: al halukat ha–historia shel ha–mishpat ha–israeli le–tkufot // Mishpatim. 1997. ¹ 27. 10. Rubenstein A. Shoftei–Eretz: Le–Rishoto ve–le–Dmuto shel Beit Mishpat Ha–Elion ba–Israel. Tel–Aviv, 1988. 11. Rubenstein A., Medina B. Ha–Mishpat ha–Konstitutzioni shel Medinat Israel. Mehadura hamishit, 1995. 12. Zilberg M. Kah Darko shel Talmud. Ierushalaim, 1969
|
Ðóñ
© 1998 – 2024 Nota Bene. Publishing Technologies. NB-Media Ltd.
