Рус Eng Cn Перевести страницу на:  
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Библиотека
ваш профиль

Вернуться к содержанию

Право и политика
Правильная ссылка на статью:

Udartsev S.F. Сosmic state: the forming and development of the idea in the history of thought

Аннотация: The article considers the philosophical-legal issues when forming and developing the idea about the cosmic state made by thinkers during different periods of time, starting from the Ancient World till Russian cosmism in the 20th century. It includes interpretations of ideas about the cosmic state in ancient mythology, in works of such thinkers as Antisfen, Diogenes of Sinope, Krates, Zeno, Platon, Iambulos, Seneca, Cicero, Dante, Augustine of Hippo, Thomas Paine, N.F. Fyodorov, K.E. Tsiolkovsky, A.F. Agienko, P.I. Ivanitsky, V.I. Vernadsky, N.K. Roerich, etc. Logical, historical, and comparative methods were used. The evaluation of the offered information contained in works of different thinkers was given from the position of a modern vision of the questions being studied, taking into consideration the level and prospects of the technical development of humanity, and the challenges of the XXIst century. It is observed that more intensive understanding of the potential of the state as a historical phenomenon took place while understanding cosmic aspects of the state in the history of political thought. Thinkers of different countries started to comprehend more deeply the unity of the world, the cosmic nature of a person and humanity, the foresight and comprehension of the coming cosmic human era and its appropriate political organization. The ideas about the cosmic state played a particular role in the liberation of the individual, and contributed to the development of the conception and forms of economic, political and legal integration, thereby extending the historical horizons of political consciousness.


Ключевые слова:

space, state, civilization, mythology, Cynics, Plato, Tsiolkovsky, Roerich, cosmism, biocosmism

Abstract: The article considers the philosophical-legal issues when forming and developing the idea about the cosmic state made by thinkers during different periods of time, starting from the Ancient World till Russian cosmism in the 20th century. It includes interpretations of ideas about the cosmic state in ancient mythology, in works of such thinkers as Antisfen, Diogenes of Sinope, Krates, Zeno, Platon, Iambulos, Seneca, Cicero, Dante, Augustine of Hippo, Thomas Paine, N.F. Fyodorov, K.E. Tsiolkovsky, A.F. Agienko, P.I. Ivanitsky, V.I. Vernadsky, N.K. Roerich, etc. Logical, historical, and comparative methods were used. The evaluation of the offered information contained in works of different thinkers was given from the position of a modern vision of the questions being studied, taking into consideration the level and prospects of the technical development of humanity, and the challenges of the XXIst century. It is observed that more intensive understanding of the potential of the state as a historical phenomenon took place while understanding cosmic aspects of the state in the history of political thought. Thinkers of different countries started to comprehend more deeply the unity of the world, the cosmic nature of a person and humanity, the foresight and comprehension of the coming cosmic human era and its appropriate political organization. The ideas about the cosmic state played a particular role in the liberation of the individual, and contributed to the development of the conception and forms of economic, political and legal integration, thereby extending the historical horizons of political consciousness.


Keywords:

Space, state, civilization, mythology, Cynics, Plato, Tsiolkovsky, Roerich, cosmism, biocosmism.


Эта статья может быть бесплатно загружена в формате PDF для чтения. Обращаем ваше внимание на необходимость соблюдения авторских прав, указания библиографической ссылки на статью при цитировании.

Скачать статью

Библиография
1. Udartsev S. F. Pravovoe gosudarstvo: smyslovye grani doktriny (iz istorii phylosophy prava) // Nauchnye trudy "Adilet" (Almaty), № 1 (9), 2001. S. 5 – 35 [in Russian].
2. Udartsev S. F. Istoriya politicheskich i pravovych ucheniy. Drevny Vostok: Akademichesky kurs. – SPb: Izdat. Dom St.-Peter. Gos. Un-ta, Izd-vo yuridicheskogo fakulteta SPbGU, 2007. – 664 s. [in Russian].
3. Shklovsky I. S. Vselennaya, zhizn, razum. Izd-vo 3-e, dop. i pererab. M.: «Science», 1973. S. 283 – 286 [in Russian].
4. Deniken E. Nebesnye uchitelya. Translated from German by G. Sachatsky. M: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2005. – 192 s. [in Russian].
5. Deniken E. Nasledie Bogov. Translated from German by S. V. Golova and A. M. Golova. M.: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2006. – 432 s. [in Russian].
6. Deniken E. Kamenny vek byl inym, Translated from German by S. V. Golova and A. M. Golova. M.: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2006. – 288 s. [in Russian].
7. Deniken E. Istoriya oshibochna. Translated from English by I. Kochneva. SPb.; Piter, 2011. – 240 s. [in Russian].
8. Sytchin Z. Kosmicheskiy kod: Gennaya inzheneriya bogov. Translated from English by Yu. Goldberg. M.: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2006. – 320 s. [in Russian].
9. Sytchin Z. Voiny bogov I ludey. Translated from English by Yu. Goldbeg. M.: Izs-vo Eksmo, 2009. – 432 s. [in Russian].
10. Isaev I. A. Vlast I zakon v kontekste irratsionalnogo. M.: Yurist, 2006. – 478 s. [in Russian].
11. Frankfort G., Frankfort G. A., Wilson J., Jacobsen T. V predvery philosophy. Duchovnye iskaniya drevnego cheloveka. Per. s ang. T. N. Tolstoy. Otv. Red. i avtor vstup. st. V. V. Ivanov. M.: Nauka, 1984. – 236 s. [in Russian].
12. Udartsev S. F. Politiko-pravovye idei i miphologiya v Mesopotamii, Hettskom tsarstve i Drevnem Irane // Problemy teorii prava i gosudarstva, istorii politiko-pravovoy mysli. Sbornik rabot uchenikov, druzey, kolleg professora O. E. Leist / Otv. Red. N. G. Belyaeva i A. A. Matyuhin. Almaty: AYu – VShP «Adilet», 2005. S. 189 – 205 and etc. [in Russian].
13. Marcic Rene. Vom Gesetzesstaat zum Richterstaat. Recht als Maß der Macht / Gedenken über den demokratischen Rechts-und Sozialstaat. Wien: Springer-Verlag, 1957. S. 7.
14. Yudhidshira // Wikipedia. Svobodnaya entsiklopedia. – http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%AE%D0% B4%D1%85%D0%B8%D1%88%D1%82%D1%85%D0%B8%D1%80%D0%B0 – 04.07.2012.
15. Tantlevsky I. R. Kniga Enoha. Arameiskie fragmenty knig enoha iz Kumrana. Evreiskaya kniga Enoha, ili knigs Nebesnyh Dvortsov. Sefer Yetzirah – Kniga Sozidaniya. Prilozhenie: Efiopskaya versiya knig Enoha. Ierusalim: Gesharim: M.: Mosty kultury, 2002. – 376 s. [in Russian].
16. Udartsev S. F. Lao-Tse. Drevneyshy predshestvenik idey samoorganizatsii kosmosa, obshestva i cheloveka // Sinergetika obrazovaniya. Mezhvusovsky sbornik (vypusk vtoroi) / Yuzhnoe otdelenie Rossiysloy akademii obrazovaniya; Moskovsky gosudarstvenny pedagogichesky universitet. Moskva; Rostov-na-Donu: Izd-vo Rostovskogo gos. Pedagogicheskogo universiteta, 2004. S. 216 – 254 [in Russian].
17. Losev A. F. Zhevs // Mifologiya. Bolshoy entsiklopedichesky slovar / Gl. red. E. M. Meletinsky. 4-е izd. M.: Bolshaya Rossiyskaya entsiklopediya,1998. S. 220 – 221 [in Russian].
18. Losev A. F. Prometey // Ibid. S. 451 [in Russian].
19. Fragmenty rannich grecheskih filosofov. Chast I. Ot epicheskih teokosmogomiy do vozniknoveniya atomistiki. Izadanir podgotovil A. V. Lebedev. M.: Nauka,1989. – 576 s. [in Russian].
20. Pythagoras. Zolotoy kanon. Figury ezoteriki. M.: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2003. – 448 s. [in Russian].
21. Nahov I. M. Kinicheskaya literature / Vstupl. A. F. Losev. M.: Glavnaya redaktsiya vostochnoy literatury izd-va «Nauka», 1981. – 303 s. [in Russian].
22. Diogenes Laetius. O zhizni, ucheniyah I izrecheniyah znamenityh pilosofov. M.: «Mysl», 1979. – 620 s. [in Russian].
23. Zenon iz Kition – biografiya, fakty iz zhizni, fotografii, spravochnaya informatsiyahttp://www.piplz.ru/page.php?id=422 – 11.06.2012 [in Russian].
24. Isaev I. A. Ideya poryadka v konservativnoy retrospective.M.: Prospect, 2011. – 400 s. [in Russian].
25. Platon. Soch.v. treh tomah. T. 3. Ch. 2. M.: «Mysl», 1972. – 678 s. [in Russian].
26. Marchenko M. N. Sravnitelnoe pravovedenie: uchebnik. 2-e izd., pererab. i dop. M.: Prospect, 2011. – 784 s. [in Russian].
27. Strazhneva Irina. Udivitelnaya zhizn Flammariona M.: Molodaya gvardiya, 1995. S. 161 – 162. [in Russian].
28. Cicero. O zakone. Kn. II. // Cicero. Dialogi. O gosudarstve.O zakonah. Izd. podgotovili. N. Veselovsky, V.O. Gorenshtein and S. L. Utchenko. M.: Izd-vo «Nauka», 1966. – 224 s. [in Russian].
29. Augustine of Hippo. O grade Bozhiem. Mn.: Harvest, M.: AST, 2000. – 1296 s. [in Russian].
30. Ernan Mak Mallin. Zhizn i intellekt za predelani Zemli: teologiya formuliruet problemy // Mnogo mirov. Novaya Vselennaya, vnezemnaya zhizn i bogoslovskiy podtext / Pod. red. Steven J. Dick; translated from English by V. L. Oleynik. N.: AST; Astrel. 2007. – 224 s. [in Russian].
31. Dante Alighieri. Monarhiya / Translated from Italian by V.P. Zubov; Commentaries by I. N. Golenishev-Kutuzov. M.: «KANON-press-Ts» – «Kuchkovo pole», 1999. [in Russian].
32. MarchenkoM.N.. Gosudarstvo I pravo v sisyeme globalnogo miroporyadka (filosofskiy aspekt) // Filosofiya prava. Kurs lektsiy v 2-h tomah. T. 1. Otv. sost. M. N. Marchenko. M.: Prospect, 2011. – 552 s. [in Russian].
33. Payne T. Izbrannye sochineniya / Pod red. M. P. Baskin. M.: Izd-vo AN SSSR, 1959. – 424 s. [in Russian].
34. Fedorov N.V. Sochineniya / Obshaya redaktsiya: A. V. Gulyga; Vstupit. statiya, primechaniya i sostav. S. G. Semenova. M.: Mysl, 1982. – 711 s. [in Russian].
35. Tsiolkovsky K. E. Kosmicheskaya filosofiya. Sbornik. Sost. D. N. Popov. Primechaniya – E. A. Logaevsly, V. V. Kazyutinsky. M.: IDLi, 2001. – 496 s. [in Russian].
36. Tsiolkovsky K.E. Moya pishushayamashinka. Dvigateli progressa. Kalugs. 1928. S. 12 [in Russian].
37. Ogurtsov A. P. Znaniya I kosmos: gnoseologiya kosmizma // Filosofiya Russkogo kosmizma. Otv. redaktory: A. P. Ogurtsov, L. V. Fesenkova. M.: Fond «Novoe tysyachiletie», 1996. – 376 s. [in Russian].
38. Kazyutinsky V. V. Kosmicheskaya folosofiya Tsiolkovskogo // Filosofiya russkogo kosmizma. Otv.redaktory: A. P. Ogurtsov, L. V. Fesenkova. M.: М.: Fond «Novoe tysyachiletie», 1996. – 376 s. [in Russian].
39. Krichevsky S. V. Aerokosmicheskaya deyatelnost: metodologicheskie, istoricheskie, sotsioprirodnye aspekty. M.: Izd-vo RAGS, 2007. – 316 s. [in Russian].
40. Udartsev S. F. Biokosmism: predposylki vozniknoveniya, kritika I revisiya teorii anarhisma / AN SSSR, Komissiya porazrabotke nauchnogo naslediya Tsiolkovskogo. IF AN SSSR, Gos. muzey kosmonavtiki im. K. E. Tsiolkovskogo // Tr. XXV chteniy, posvash. Razrabotke nauchnogo naslediya I razvitiya idey K. E. Tsiolkovskogo (Kaluga, 11–14.09.1990). Sektsiya: K. E. Tsiolkovsky I filosofskie problemy osvoeniya kosmosa: Kosmonavtika I perspektivy chelovechestva: filos-sotsialniy aspekt. Sb. st. M.: IIET AN SSSR, 1991. S. 233 – 242 [in Russian].
41. Udartsev S. F. Biokosmism: predchuvstvie kosmicheskoy ery / Mezhdunarodniy god kosmosa [1992] / Avtor statyi I publikatsii // Prostor (A.). 1992. № 4. S. 160 – 166 [in Russian].
42. Udartsev S. F. Politicheskaya I pravovaya teoriya anarhisma v Rossii: istoriya I sovremennost. Almaty: Kazakhstan; VShP «Adilet», 1994. – 382 s. [in Russian].
43. Roerich N. K. Sem Velikih Tain Kosmosa. Bishkek: MRIP «Feniks», 1991. – 192 s. [in Russian].
44. Muldashev Ernst Rifgatovich // Wikipedia. Svobodnaya entsiklopedia. – http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Мулдашев,_Эрнст_Рифгатович – 07.05.2012. [in Russian].
45. Torchinov E. A. Puti filosofii Vostoka i Zapada: poznanie zapredelnogo. SPb.: «Azbuka klassiki», «St. Petersburg Oriental Studies», 2007. – 480 s. [in Russian].
46. Seklitova L. A., Strelnikova L. L. Slovar kosmichesloy filosofii. M.: Amrita-Russ, 2004. – 208 s. [in Russian].
47. Platonova T. Yu. O gosudarstve. M.: Beliy ashram, 2000. – 284 s. [in Russian].
48. Pavroz, A. V. The Welfare State: the Nature of Politics and Fundamental Contradictions // Право и политика. 2011. № 11. C. 21-30.
49. Udartsev, S.F. The idea of the cosmic state in the history of political thought. // Право и политика. 2012. № 8. C. 1386-1399.
50. Ursul, A.D. Globalization of law and global law: conceptual and methodological problems // Право и политика. 2012.№ 8. С. 1284-1297.
References
1. Udartsev S. F. Pravovoe gosudarstvo: smyslovye grani doktriny (iz istorii phylosophy prava) // Nauchnye trudy "Adilet" (Almaty), № 1 (9), 2001. S. 5 – 35 [in Russian].
2. Udartsev S. F. Istoriya politicheskich i pravovych ucheniy. Drevny Vostok: Akademichesky kurs. – SPb: Izdat. Dom St.-Peter. Gos. Un-ta, Izd-vo yuridicheskogo fakulteta SPbGU, 2007. – 664 s. [in Russian].
3. Shklovsky I. S. Vselennaya, zhizn, razum. Izd-vo 3-e, dop. i pererab. M.: «Science», 1973. S. 283 – 286 [in Russian].
4. Deniken E. Nebesnye uchitelya. Translated from German by G. Sachatsky. M: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2005. – 192 s. [in Russian].
5. Deniken E. Nasledie Bogov. Translated from German by S. V. Golova and A. M. Golova. M.: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2006. – 432 s. [in Russian].
6. Deniken E. Kamenny vek byl inym, Translated from German by S. V. Golova and A. M. Golova. M.: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2006. – 288 s. [in Russian].
7. Deniken E. Istoriya oshibochna. Translated from English by I. Kochneva. SPb.; Piter, 2011. – 240 s. [in Russian].
8. Sytchin Z. Kosmicheskiy kod: Gennaya inzheneriya bogov. Translated from English by Yu. Goldberg. M.: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2006. – 320 s. [in Russian].
9. Sytchin Z. Voiny bogov I ludey. Translated from English by Yu. Goldbeg. M.: Izs-vo Eksmo, 2009. – 432 s. [in Russian].
10. Isaev I. A. Vlast I zakon v kontekste irratsionalnogo. M.: Yurist, 2006. – 478 s. [in Russian].
11. Frankfort G., Frankfort G. A., Wilson J., Jacobsen T. V predvery philosophy. Duchovnye iskaniya drevnego cheloveka. Per. s ang. T. N. Tolstoy. Otv. Red. i avtor vstup. st. V. V. Ivanov. M.: Nauka, 1984. – 236 s. [in Russian].
12. Udartsev S. F. Politiko-pravovye idei i miphologiya v Mesopotamii, Hettskom tsarstve i Drevnem Irane // Problemy teorii prava i gosudarstva, istorii politiko-pravovoy mysli. Sbornik rabot uchenikov, druzey, kolleg professora O. E. Leist / Otv. Red. N. G. Belyaeva i A. A. Matyuhin. Almaty: AYu – VShP «Adilet», 2005. S. 189 – 205 and etc. [in Russian].
13. Marcic Rene. Vom Gesetzesstaat zum Richterstaat. Recht als Maß der Macht / Gedenken über den demokratischen Rechts-und Sozialstaat. Wien: Springer-Verlag, 1957. S. 7.
14. Yudhidshira // Wikipedia. Svobodnaya entsiklopedia. – http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%AE%D0% B4%D1%85%D0%B8%D1%88%D1%82%D1%85%D0%B8%D1%80%D0%B0 – 04.07.2012.
15. Tantlevsky I. R. Kniga Enoha. Arameiskie fragmenty knig enoha iz Kumrana. Evreiskaya kniga Enoha, ili knigs Nebesnyh Dvortsov. Sefer Yetzirah – Kniga Sozidaniya. Prilozhenie: Efiopskaya versiya knig Enoha. Ierusalim: Gesharim: M.: Mosty kultury, 2002. – 376 s. [in Russian].
16. Udartsev S. F. Lao-Tse. Drevneyshy predshestvenik idey samoorganizatsii kosmosa, obshestva i cheloveka // Sinergetika obrazovaniya. Mezhvusovsky sbornik (vypusk vtoroi) / Yuzhnoe otdelenie Rossiysloy akademii obrazovaniya; Moskovsky gosudarstvenny pedagogichesky universitet. Moskva; Rostov-na-Donu: Izd-vo Rostovskogo gos. Pedagogicheskogo universiteta, 2004. S. 216 – 254 [in Russian].
17. Losev A. F. Zhevs // Mifologiya. Bolshoy entsiklopedichesky slovar / Gl. red. E. M. Meletinsky. 4-e izd. M.: Bolshaya Rossiyskaya entsiklopediya,1998. S. 220 – 221 [in Russian].
18. Losev A. F. Prometey // Ibid. S. 451 [in Russian].
19. Fragmenty rannich grecheskih filosofov. Chast I. Ot epicheskih teokosmogomiy do vozniknoveniya atomistiki. Izadanir podgotovil A. V. Lebedev. M.: Nauka,1989. – 576 s. [in Russian].
20. Pythagoras. Zolotoy kanon. Figury ezoteriki. M.: Izd-vo Eksmo, 2003. – 448 s. [in Russian].
21. Nahov I. M. Kinicheskaya literature / Vstupl. A. F. Losev. M.: Glavnaya redaktsiya vostochnoy literatury izd-va «Nauka», 1981. – 303 s. [in Russian].
22. Diogenes Laetius. O zhizni, ucheniyah I izrecheniyah znamenityh pilosofov. M.: «Mysl», 1979. – 620 s. [in Russian].
23. Zenon iz Kition – biografiya, fakty iz zhizni, fotografii, spravochnaya informatsiyahttp://www.piplz.ru/page.php?id=422 – 11.06.2012 [in Russian].
24. Isaev I. A. Ideya poryadka v konservativnoy retrospective.M.: Prospect, 2011. – 400 s. [in Russian].
25. Platon. Soch.v. treh tomah. T. 3. Ch. 2. M.: «Mysl», 1972. – 678 s. [in Russian].
26. Marchenko M. N. Sravnitelnoe pravovedenie: uchebnik. 2-e izd., pererab. i dop. M.: Prospect, 2011. – 784 s. [in Russian].
27. Strazhneva Irina. Udivitelnaya zhizn Flammariona M.: Molodaya gvardiya, 1995. S. 161 – 162. [in Russian].
28. Cicero. O zakone. Kn. II. // Cicero. Dialogi. O gosudarstve.O zakonah. Izd. podgotovili. N. Veselovsky, V.O. Gorenshtein and S. L. Utchenko. M.: Izd-vo «Nauka», 1966. – 224 s. [in Russian].
29. Augustine of Hippo. O grade Bozhiem. Mn.: Harvest, M.: AST, 2000. – 1296 s. [in Russian].
30. Ernan Mak Mallin. Zhizn i intellekt za predelani Zemli: teologiya formuliruet problemy // Mnogo mirov. Novaya Vselennaya, vnezemnaya zhizn i bogoslovskiy podtext / Pod. red. Steven J. Dick; translated from English by V. L. Oleynik. N.: AST; Astrel. 2007. – 224 s. [in Russian].
31. Dante Alighieri. Monarhiya / Translated from Italian by V.P. Zubov; Commentaries by I. N. Golenishev-Kutuzov. M.: «KANON-press-Ts» – «Kuchkovo pole», 1999. [in Russian].
32. MarchenkoM.N.. Gosudarstvo I pravo v sisyeme globalnogo miroporyadka (filosofskiy aspekt) // Filosofiya prava. Kurs lektsiy v 2-h tomah. T. 1. Otv. sost. M. N. Marchenko. M.: Prospect, 2011. – 552 s. [in Russian].
33. Payne T. Izbrannye sochineniya / Pod red. M. P. Baskin. M.: Izd-vo AN SSSR, 1959. – 424 s. [in Russian].
34. Fedorov N.V. Sochineniya / Obshaya redaktsiya: A. V. Gulyga; Vstupit. statiya, primechaniya i sostav. S. G. Semenova. M.: Mysl, 1982. – 711 s. [in Russian].
35. Tsiolkovsky K. E. Kosmicheskaya filosofiya. Sbornik. Sost. D. N. Popov. Primechaniya – E. A. Logaevsly, V. V. Kazyutinsky. M.: IDLi, 2001. – 496 s. [in Russian].
36. Tsiolkovsky K.E. Moya pishushayamashinka. Dvigateli progressa. Kalugs. 1928. S. 12 [in Russian].
37. Ogurtsov A. P. Znaniya I kosmos: gnoseologiya kosmizma // Filosofiya Russkogo kosmizma. Otv. redaktory: A. P. Ogurtsov, L. V. Fesenkova. M.: Fond «Novoe tysyachiletie», 1996. – 376 s. [in Russian].
38. Kazyutinsky V. V. Kosmicheskaya folosofiya Tsiolkovskogo // Filosofiya russkogo kosmizma. Otv.redaktory: A. P. Ogurtsov, L. V. Fesenkova. M.: M.: Fond «Novoe tysyachiletie», 1996. – 376 s. [in Russian].
39. Krichevsky S. V. Aerokosmicheskaya deyatelnost: metodologicheskie, istoricheskie, sotsioprirodnye aspekty. M.: Izd-vo RAGS, 2007. – 316 s. [in Russian].
40. Udartsev S. F. Biokosmism: predposylki vozniknoveniya, kritika I revisiya teorii anarhisma / AN SSSR, Komissiya porazrabotke nauchnogo naslediya Tsiolkovskogo. IF AN SSSR, Gos. muzey kosmonavtiki im. K. E. Tsiolkovskogo // Tr. XXV chteniy, posvash. Razrabotke nauchnogo naslediya I razvitiya idey K. E. Tsiolkovskogo (Kaluga, 11–14.09.1990). Sektsiya: K. E. Tsiolkovsky I filosofskie problemy osvoeniya kosmosa: Kosmonavtika I perspektivy chelovechestva: filos-sotsialniy aspekt. Sb. st. M.: IIET AN SSSR, 1991. S. 233 – 242 [in Russian].
41. Udartsev S. F. Biokosmism: predchuvstvie kosmicheskoy ery / Mezhdunarodniy god kosmosa [1992] / Avtor statyi I publikatsii // Prostor (A.). 1992. № 4. S. 160 – 166 [in Russian].
42. Udartsev S. F. Politicheskaya I pravovaya teoriya anarhisma v Rossii: istoriya I sovremennost. Almaty: Kazakhstan; VShP «Adilet», 1994. – 382 s. [in Russian].
43. Roerich N. K. Sem Velikih Tain Kosmosa. Bishkek: MRIP «Feniks», 1991. – 192 s. [in Russian].
44. Muldashev Ernst Rifgatovich // Wikipedia. Svobodnaya entsiklopedia. – http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muldashev,_Ernst_Rifgatovich – 07.05.2012. [in Russian].
45. Torchinov E. A. Puti filosofii Vostoka i Zapada: poznanie zapredelnogo. SPb.: «Azbuka klassiki», «St. Petersburg Oriental Studies», 2007. – 480 s. [in Russian].
46. Seklitova L. A., Strelnikova L. L. Slovar kosmichesloy filosofii. M.: Amrita-Russ, 2004. – 208 s. [in Russian].
47. Platonova T. Yu. O gosudarstve. M.: Beliy ashram, 2000. – 284 s. [in Russian].
48. Pavroz, A. V. The Welfare State: the Nature of Politics and Fundamental Contradictions // Pravo i politika. 2011. № 11. C. 21-30.
49. Udartsev, S.F. The idea of the cosmic state in the history of political thought. // Pravo i politika. 2012. № 8. C. 1386-1399.
50. Ursul, A.D. Globalization of law and global law: conceptual and methodological problems // Pravo i politika. 2012.№ 8. S. 1284-1297.