Правильная ссылка на статью:
Avatkov, V.A., Badranov, A.Sh..
The pan-Turkist aspect within the discourse of the modern Tatar national movement.
// National Security / nota bene. – 2014. – № 2.
– С. 283-291.
DOI: 10.7256/2073-8560.2014.2.10884.
рубрика Внутренние угрозы и контрмеры
DOI: 10.7256/2073-8560.2014.2.10884
Читать статью
Аннотация: The object of studies in this article includes national movements in the territory of the Russian Federation,
and, more specifically, the Tatar national movement, which is one of the most active actors in the domestic political
interactions in Russia. The ethnic political and federal development of the Russian Federation passed through the
stage of separatist “sovereignty parade”, and as a result of the reform of “strengthening the government vertical” in
early 2000, it is now characterized with the lower activity an role of national movements in the political discourse of
national and territorial subjects of the Russian Federation. At the current stage in some regions national movement of
the native peoples of these territories are out of the political arena due to degradation and discrediting of their ideas.
In other regions these movements were transformed into other institutional forms, or their ideas gained new understanding
among the national elites. The Republic of Tatarstan is quite interesting object to study from the standpoint
of the ethnic and political development of the peoples of Russia. The main method of studies therefore is a systemic approach, allowing to include separate processes into the general global trends. The pan-Turkist ideology shows flexible
mechanisms and forms of influence on the Tatar community. However, this ideology needs to address the basic
postulates of the time of its genesis in some way. That is why the scientific and expert community of Russia should
provide due evaluation to the “Idel-Urals” project as a radical theory provoking separatism in the Urals and Volga
Region republics. Generally, the pan-Turkism is a complicated ideology, including various theoretical concepts and
ideologems, which claims a rather large theory and a large number of ethnic groups. When this ideology is analyzed
from the critical standpoint it becomes obvious that the pan-Turkist project is pragmatically used by Turkey. However,
some politicians and public figures tend to evaluate implementation of pan-Turkist ideas as a revival of true national
identity (for example, in the Bashkir and the Tatar national movements). However, the pan-Turkist ideology provides
for a final goal of assimilation of all of the Turkic peoples into one super-ethnos based upon the Turkish nation, rather
than providing only for cultural and political unity. In turn, it means that the Turkic peoples shall be destroyed as
separate ethnic groups. At the age of globalization, when we face the choice among the paths for the development, we
may not ignore geopolitical realities and threats. The ongoing global processes, fall of regimes under other regimes,
victories of one ideology over another show the reform of the global structure and order. The national intellectuals
of different peoples should be very careful when choosing concepts for the modernization of their ethnic groups,
otherwise, there may be a situation when having “found their path for development” based on a certain ideological
construction the entire peoples may become just mechanisms and instruments for the achievement of geopolitical
goals of foreign states.
Ключевые слова: nationalism, Tatarstan, pan-Turkism, national movement, Turkism, globalization, security, national security, soft power, sovereignty.
Контактная информация: Avatkov, Vladimir Alekseevich, 119454, Russia, Moskva, prospect Vernadskogo, 76.
Библиография:
Avatkov V.A., Badranov A.Sh. «Myagkaya sila» Turtsii vo vnutrenney politike Rossii // Pravo i upravlenie. XXI vek. 2013. №2 (27). S. 5-10.
VTOTs provel miting u teatra im. Kamala // http://www.business-gazeta.ru/article/89496/
Chuvashskie flagi na dne pamyati i skorbi v Kazani // http://anticor-21.livejournal.com/267414.html
Ivanova V.V. Volk okhranyayushchiy i volk napadayushchiy// Bestiariy II. Zoomorfizmy Azii: dvizhenie vo vremeni. — SPb.: MAE RAN, 2012. S. 95-96.
Terekhov R.S. Vliyanie ideologii pantyurkizma na vneshnyuyu politiku Osmanskoy imperii i Turetskoy respubliki v XX veke: diss. … kand. ist. nauk. – Nizhniy Novgorod, 2011. S. 184
Novye alfavity i starye problemy // www.fergananews.com/article.php?id=5079&print=1
Latinizatsiya uzbekskogo alfavita: kommentarii spetsialistov // www.fergananews.com/article.php?id=5118&print=1
Tatarstan ostavili bez latinits'y // http://lenta.ru/articles/2004/11/16/language
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 16 noyabrya 2004 g. N 16-P // http://www.rg.ru/2004/11/23/tatar-yazyk-dok.html
Natsizm volzhskogo razliva // http://svpressa.ru/society/article/64977/
Sm.: D. M. Iskhakov Etnografiya tatarskogo naroda, Kazan', Magarif, 2004; D. M. Iskhakov Tatarskaya natsiya: istoriya i sovremennoe razvitie. Nauchnaya publitsistika. — Kazan', 2004
Orlova I.B., Etnizatsiya istoricheskogo znaniya v postsovetskikh gosudarstvakh //Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya, № 10, Oktyabr' 2009, C. 126-135
Tam zhe.
Moskva-Kazan': tysyacheletie spustya // www.pravaya.ru/look/4520
Iskhakov R. L. Ideologema «Idel'-Ural» v svete kontseptsii «kul'turnogo gnezda». (K voprosu o pererastanii kul'turnogo gnezda v kul'turnyy tsentr) / R.L. Iskhakov // Dergachevskie chteniya-2011. Russkaya literatura: natsional'noe razvitie i regional'nye osobennosti: materialy X Vseros. nauch. konf. — Ekaterinburg, 2012. — T. 3. — S. 93.
Gilyazov I.A. Legion «Idel'-Ural». Predstaviteli narodov Povolzh'ya i Priural'ya pod znamenami «tret'ego reykha». – Kazan': Tatarskoe knizhnoe izdatel'stvo, 2005. – 383 s.
Ursul A.D. Natsional'naya ideya i global'nye protsessy: bezopasnost', ustoychivoe razvitie, noosferogenez // NB: Natsional'naya bezopasnost'.-2013.-2.-C. 1-66. URL: http://www.e-notabene.ru/nb/article_541.html
V.L. Bunchuk Regional'naya politika federativnogo gosudarstva kak mekhanizm optimizatsii i sovershenstvovaniya federativnykh otnosheniy // Natsional'naya bezopasnost' / nota bene.-2012.-6.-C. 22-27.
Bocharnikov I.V. Fenomen patriotizma v mirovoy politicheskoy istorii // Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya.-2013.-4.-C. 513-518. DOI: 10.7256/2305-560X.2013.4.9271.
Kuznetsova A.I. Rol' natsional'noy identichnosti v mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniyakh na sovremennom etape // Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya.-2013.-2.-C. 185-191. DOI: 10.7256/2305-560Kh.2013.02.11.
Noyanzina O.E., Goncharova N.P., Maksimova S.G., Avdeeva G.C. Sovremennye vyzovy bezopasnosti: otsenka riska podverzhennosti ekstremistkim i terroristicheskim ugrozam v usloviyakh regional'nykh sotsiumov // NB: Natsional'naya bezopasnost'.-2012.-1.-C. 213-254. DOI: 10.7256/2306-0417.2012.1.92. URL: http://www.e-notabene.ru/nb/article_92.html
K.A.Bogatyrev. Krymskie tatary i etnokonfentsional'nyy konflikt v regione v nachale XXI v.. // Politika i Obshchestvo.-2009.-№ 12.
V.V Bublikov. Islamizatsiya Evropy kak sledstvie dekhristianizatsii i demograficheskogo krizisa. // Trendy i upravlenie.-2013.-№ 2.-C. 156-164. DOI: 10.7256/2307-9118.2013.2.5328.
Yu.A. Razumov Odno iz napravleniy sovershenstvovaniya zakonodatel'stva Rossiyskoy Federatsii v sfere pogranichnoy deyatel'nosti s uchetom natsional'no-pravovoy implementatsii // Natsional'naya bezopasnost' / nota bene.-2013.-1.-C. 152-156. DOI: 10.7256/2073-8560.2013.01.15.
// http://rus.ruvr.ru/2013_10_11/Djusen-Kaseinov-TJURKSOJ-nazivajut-JUNESKO-tjurkskogo-mira-9571/
V KFU otkrylsya Nauchno-obrazovatel'nyy tsentr izucheniya Turtsii //www.kpfu.ru/main_page?p_cid=25200
Dyusen Kaseinov: "TYuRKSOY nazyvayut YuNESKO tyurkskogo mira"
Mkrtychyan A.A. Pantyurkizm v geostrategii Turtsii na Kavkaze kak global'naya problema sovremennykh mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy (politologicheskiy analiz): diss. … dokt. polit. nauk. – M., 2003. S. 39-40
Ob'em turetskikh investitsiy v Tatarstan sostavil $2 mlrd // http://www.regnum.ru/news/1702492.html#ixzz2iYKsvC3z
Ofitsial'nyy sayt STM «Azatlyk»// http://azatliq.info/ru/news.
Informatsionnoe izdanie tatarskoy partii natsional'noy nezavisimosti «Ittifak» // http://azatlyk-vatan.blogspot.ru/.
Terekhov R.S. Vliyanie ideologii pantyurkizma na vneshnyuyu politiku Osmanskoy imperii i Turetskoy respubliki v XX veke: diss. … kand. ist. nauk. – Nizhniy Novgorod, 2011. S. 27.
Mukhammetdinov R.F. Zarozhdenie i evolyutsiya tyurkizma. – Kazan': izd.-vo «Zaman», 1996. S. 55-63.
Iskhakov R. L. Ideologema «Idel'-Ural» v svete kontseptsii «kul'turnogo gnezda». (K voprosu o pererastanii kul'turnogo gnezda v kul'turnyy tsentr) / R.L. Iskhakov // Dergachevskie chteniya – 2011. Russkaya literatura: natsional'noe razvitie i regional'nye osobennosti: materialy X Vseros. nauch. konf. – Ekaterinburg, 2012. – T. 3. – S. 91-98.
Informatsionnoe izdanie Vsetatarskogo obshchestvennogo tsentra (VTOTs) // http://tatar-centr.blogspot.ru/2012/07/blog-post_14.html.
Kh.V. Dzutsev, Yu.Yu. Sinelina. Rasprostranenie religioznogo techeniya vakhkhabizm v respublikakh Severo-Kavkazskogo Federal'nogo okruga Rossiyskoy Federatsii: etnosotsiologicheskiy analiz. // Natsional'naya bezopasnost' / nota bene.-2013.-№ 1.-C. 88-122. DOI: 10.7256/2073-8560.2013.01.9.
D.S. Ryazanov. Predstavlenie o sushchnosti "islamskogo gosudarstva" v knige Sayida Kutba "Vekhi na puti". // Filosofiya i kul'tura.-2011.-№ 9.-C. 44-50. DOI: .
References (transliteration):
Avatkov V.A., Badranov A.Sh. «Myagkaya sila» Turtsii vo vnutrenney politike Rossii // Pravo i upravlenie. XXI vek. 2013. №2 (27). S. 5-10.
VTOTs provel miting u teatra im. Kamala // http://www.business-gazeta.ru/article/89496/
Chuvashskie flagi na dne pamyati i skorbi v Kazani // http://anticor-21.livejournal.com/267414.html
Ivanova V.V. Volk okhranyayushchiy i volk napadayushchiy// Bestiariy II. Zoomorfizmy Azii: dvizhenie vo vremeni. — SPb.: MAE RAN, 2012. S. 95-96.
Terekhov R.S. Vliyanie ideologii pantyurkizma na vneshnyuyu politiku Osmanskoy imperii i Turetskoy respubliki v XX veke: diss. … kand. ist. nauk. – Nizhniy Novgorod, 2011. S. 184
Novye alfavity i starye problemy // www.fergananews.com/article.php?id=5079&print=1
Latinizatsiya uzbekskogo alfavita: kommentarii spetsialistov // www.fergananews.com/article.php?id=5118&print=1
Tatarstan ostavili bez latinits'y // http://lenta.ru/articles/2004/11/16/language
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 16 noyabrya 2004 g. N 16-P // http://www.rg.ru/2004/11/23/tatar-yazyk-dok.html
Natsizm volzhskogo razliva // http://svpressa.ru/society/article/64977/
Sm.: D. M. Iskhakov Etnografiya tatarskogo naroda, Kazan', Magarif, 2004; D. M. Iskhakov Tatarskaya natsiya: istoriya i sovremennoe razvitie. Nauchnaya publitsistika. — Kazan', 2004
Orlova I.B., Etnizatsiya istoricheskogo znaniya v postsovetskikh gosudarstvakh //Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya, № 10, Oktyabr' 2009, C. 126-135
Tam zhe.
Moskva-Kazan': tysyacheletie spustya // www.pravaya.ru/look/4520
Iskhakov R. L. Ideologema «Idel'-Ural» v svete kontseptsii «kul'turnogo gnezda». (K voprosu o pererastanii kul'turnogo gnezda v kul'turnyy tsentr) / R.L. Iskhakov // Dergachevskie chteniya-2011. Russkaya literatura: natsional'noe razvitie i regional'nye osobennosti: materialy X Vseros. nauch. konf. — Ekaterinburg, 2012. — T. 3. — S. 93.
Gilyazov I.A. Legion «Idel'-Ural». Predstaviteli narodov Povolzh'ya i Priural'ya pod znamenami «tret'ego reykha». – Kazan': Tatarskoe knizhnoe izdatel'stvo, 2005. – 383 s.
Ursul A.D. Natsional'naya ideya i global'nye protsessy: bezopasnost', ustoychivoe razvitie, noosferogenez // NB: Natsional'naya bezopasnost'.-2013.-2.-C. 1-66. URL: http://www.e-notabene.ru/nb/article_541.html
V.L. Bunchuk Regional'naya politika federativnogo gosudarstva kak mekhanizm optimizatsii i sovershenstvovaniya federativnykh otnosheniy // Natsional'naya bezopasnost' / nota bene.-2012.-6.-C. 22-27.
Bocharnikov I.V. Fenomen patriotizma v mirovoy politicheskoy istorii // Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya.-2013.-4.-C. 513-518. DOI: 10.7256/2305-560X.2013.4.9271.
Kuznetsova A.I. Rol' natsional'noy identichnosti v mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniyakh na sovremennom etape // Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya.-2013.-2.-C. 185-191. DOI: 10.7256/2305-560Kh.2013.02.11.
Noyanzina O.E., Goncharova N.P., Maksimova S.G., Avdeeva G.C. Sovremennye vyzovy bezopasnosti: otsenka riska podverzhennosti ekstremistkim i terroristicheskim ugrozam v usloviyakh regional'nykh sotsiumov // NB: Natsional'naya bezopasnost'.-2012.-1.-C. 213-254. DOI: 10.7256/2306-0417.2012.1.92. URL: http://www.e-notabene.ru/nb/article_92.html
K.A.Bogatyrev. Krymskie tatary i etnokonfentsional'nyy konflikt v regione v nachale XXI v.. // Politika i Obshchestvo.-2009.-№ 12.
V.V Bublikov. Islamizatsiya Evropy kak sledstvie dekhristianizatsii i demograficheskogo krizisa. // Trendy i upravlenie.-2013.-№ 2.-C. 156-164. DOI: 10.7256/2307-9118.2013.2.5328.
Yu.A. Razumov Odno iz napravleniy sovershenstvovaniya zakonodatel'stva Rossiyskoy Federatsii v sfere pogranichnoy deyatel'nosti s uchetom natsional'no-pravovoy implementatsii // Natsional'naya bezopasnost' / nota bene.-2013.-1.-C. 152-156. DOI: 10.7256/2073-8560.2013.01.15.
// http://rus.ruvr.ru/2013_10_11/Djusen-Kaseinov-TJURKSOJ-nazivajut-JUNESKO-tjurkskogo-mira-9571/
V KFU otkrylsya Nauchno-obrazovatel'nyy tsentr izucheniya Turtsii //www.kpfu.ru/main_page?p_cid=25200
Dyusen Kaseinov: "TYuRKSOY nazyvayut YuNESKO tyurkskogo mira"
Mkrtychyan A.A. Pantyurkizm v geostrategii Turtsii na Kavkaze kak global'naya problema sovremennykh mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy (politologicheskiy analiz): diss. … dokt. polit. nauk. – M., 2003. S. 39-40
Ob'em turetskikh investitsiy v Tatarstan sostavil $2 mlrd // http://www.regnum.ru/news/1702492.html#ixzz2iYKsvC3z
Ofitsial'nyy sayt STM «Azatlyk»// http://azatliq.info/ru/news.
Informatsionnoe izdanie tatarskoy partii natsional'noy nezavisimosti «Ittifak» // http://azatlyk-vatan.blogspot.ru/.
Terekhov R.S. Vliyanie ideologii pantyurkizma na vneshnyuyu politiku Osmanskoy imperii i Turetskoy respubliki v XX veke: diss. … kand. ist. nauk. – Nizhniy Novgorod, 2011. S. 27.
Mukhammetdinov R.F. Zarozhdenie i evolyutsiya tyurkizma. – Kazan': izd.-vo «Zaman», 1996. S. 55-63.
Iskhakov R. L. Ideologema «Idel'-Ural» v svete kontseptsii «kul'turnogo gnezda». (K voprosu o pererastanii kul'turnogo gnezda v kul'turnyy tsentr) / R.L. Iskhakov // Dergachevskie chteniya – 2011. Russkaya literatura: natsional'noe razvitie i regional'nye osobennosti: materialy X Vseros. nauch. konf. – Ekaterinburg, 2012. – T. 3. – S. 91-98.
Informatsionnoe izdanie Vsetatarskogo obshchestvennogo tsentra (VTOTs) // http://tatar-centr.blogspot.ru/2012/07/blog-post_14.html.
Kh.V. Dzutsev, Yu.Yu. Sinelina. Rasprostranenie religioznogo techeniya vakhkhabizm v respublikakh Severo-Kavkazskogo Federal'nogo okruga Rossiyskoy Federatsii: etnosotsiologicheskiy analiz. // Natsional'naya bezopasnost' / nota bene.-2013.-№ 1.-C. 88-122. DOI: 10.7256/2073-8560.2013.01.9.
D.S. Ryazanov. Predstavlenie o sushchnosti "islamskogo gosudarstva" v knige Sayida Kutba "Vekhi na puti". // Filosofiya i kul'tura.-2011.-№ 9.-C. 44-50. DOI: .