Правильная ссылка на статью:
Egorov, V.G..
Regime transformation
of the post-Soviet
independent states
// International relations. – 2013. – № 4.
– С. 452-470.
DOI: 10.7256/2305-560X.2013.4.9398.
рубрика ПОЛИТИЧЕСКАЯ МОДЕРНИЗАЦИЯ МЕЖДУНАРОДНЫХ ОТНОШЕНИЙ
DOI: 10.7256/2305-560X.2013.4.9398
Читать статью
Аннотация: The article presents the author’s point of view on contents and vectors of regime transformation of the new
independent states, which differs considerably from a traditional point of view on the perspectives of the post-Soviet
political modernization. In spite of the unity of historical destinies of peoples and states in the post-Soviet territory,
the Russian political science pays little attention to the comparative analysis of the specific features of the political
development of newly independent states. Existing works in this sphere present an exception to a rule. However, the
mutual interdependency of the global processes, as well as the special role of matters facilitating or precluding the
formation of regional communities, requires the need to fill the gap in the social sciences. The political orders of the
post-Soviet independent states have a common feature, which is due to the historic context of their formation. In
the opinion of most researchers, studying the newly independent states, one characteristic feature of their political
landscape is immaturity of the new forms of political organizations, including national state formations, not having the
formal elements of sovereign states.
Ключевые слова: international relations, politics, Russia, the CIS, political transformation, political regime, democratization, post-Soviet territory, integration.
Контактная информация: Egorov, Vladimir Georgievich, 101000, Moskva, ul. Polyanka Bolshaya, 7/10, str. 3.
Библиография:
1. Anrmeier H. Deutsche Reichstagstagsakten. Deutsche Reichstagstagsakten unter Maximilian I. Band 5: Reichstag
vonWorms 1495. — Vandenhoeck + Ruprecht, 1981.
2. Hoeffler A., Bates R.H., Fayad G. Income and democracy: Lipset’s Law Revisited. Working Paper №12/295. December
17, 2012.
3. Mann S.R. Chaos Theory in Strategic Thought // Parametes. Autum 1992. P. 62.
4. Agentstvo po statistike Respubliki Kazakhstan // URL: http://investfunds.kz/news/investicii-v-osnovnoj-kapital-vkazahstane-
v-yanvare-aprele-vyrosli-na-79-ia-novosti-kazahstan-33389/
5. Alieva L. Vliyanie «arabskikh» revolyutsiy na postsovetskoe prostranstvo: «Konets budet tot zhe» // URL: http://
www.regnum.ru/news
6. V Turtsii Nazarbaev predlozhil ob'edinit' 200 mln tyurkov // Kazakhinform. 13.10.2012.
7. Grozin A.V. Turkmenistan: elita, tekushchaya situatsiya i perspektivy. — M.: Institut stran SNG, 2013.
8. Dakhin V.N. Politicheskie problemy postsovetskogo prostranstva // Kuda idet Rossiya?.. Sotsial'naya transfor-
matsiya postsovetskogo prostranstva / pod obshch. red. T.I. Zaslavskoy. — M.: Aspekt Press, 2006.
9. Demidov S.M. Postsovetskiy Turkmenistan. — M., 2002.
10. Zarubezhnye seta chinovnikov zapretyat v uskorennom rezhime // Kommersant. №241 (5026). 20.10.2012.
11. Zinov'ev A.A. Zapad: izbrannye sochineniya / A.A. Zinov'ev, vstup. Stat'ya G.V. Osipova, sostavlenie Yu.N. So-
lodukhina. — M.: Astrel', 2008.
12. Iglton T. Pochemu Marks byl prav. — M., 2012.
13. Integratsionnyy barometr. EABR 2012. Evraziyskiy Bank Razvitiya. Tsentr integratsionnykh issledovaniy. —
SPb., 2012.
14. Issledovatel'skiy proekt: «Vospriyatie molodezh'yu novykh nezavisimykh gosudarstv istorii sovetskogo i
postsovetskogo periodov». Aprel'-may 2009 g. Kratkiy analiticheskiy otchet. — M., 2009.
15. Konstitutsiya Turkmenistana // URL: http://www.turkmenistan.ru/?page_id=9&lang_id=ru&elem_
id=2251&type=event&sort=date_desc
16. Kosolapov N. Proobraz postkapitalizma // Rossiya v global'noy politike. T. 11. №1. Yanvar'-fevral'. 2013.
17. Kuz'mina E.M. Politicheskoe razvitie Uzbekistana na sovremennom etape // Politicheskie protsessy v novykh nezavisimykh gosudarstvakh. Vestnik nauchnoy informatsii. — №3. — 2011.
18. Kurits S., Vorob'ev V. Karkas konstitutsii gosudarstva // Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn'. — №4. — 2013.
19. Lavrov S. Vneshnepoliticheskaya filosofiya Rossii // Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn'. — №3. — 2013.
20. Mel'vil' A.Yu. Faktory rezhimnykh transformatsiy gosudarstvennoy sostoyatel'nosti v postkommunistiche-
skikh stranakh: preprint WP14/2011/04 (ch. 1) / Mel'vil' A.Yu., Stukal D.K., Mironyuk M.G. Nats. Issledovaniya
universiteta «Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki». — M.: Izd. Dom «Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki», 2011.
21. Mel'vil' A.Yu. Faktory rezhimnykh transformatsiy i tipy gosudarstvennoy sostoyatel'nosti v postkommuni-
sticheskikh stranakh: preprint WP14/2011/04 (ch. 1)/Mel'vil' A.Yu., Stukal D.K., Mironyuk M.G. Nats. issledova-
niya universiteta «Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki». — M.: Izd. Dom «Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki», 2011.
22. Ministerstvo inostrannykh del RF. Ofitsial'nyy sayt. Perechen' osnovnykh pretenziy i rekomendatsiy mezhdu-
narodnykh organizatsiy i NPO k Latvii po pravam natsional'nykh men'shinstv // URL: http://www.mid.ru/bdomp/
Ns-dgpch.nsf/05a95604fc81125843256da400378f3b/432569ee00522d3c43256e00003017ad!OpenDocument
23. Monitoring migratsionnykh nastroeniy sootechestvennikov prozhivayushchikh za rubezhom. M.: MID RF. 2012.
24. Musaev O. Prava cheloveka v Turkmenistane — na vysote demokraticheskikh preobrazovaniy // URL: http://
niyazov.sitecity.ru/ltext_2010114405.phtml?p_ident=ltext_2010114405.p_0411151212
25. Nablyudateli sochli vybory na Ukraine neprozrachnymi // URL: http://top.rbc.ru/politics/29/10/2012/822380.shtml
26. Nazarbaev o razvitii demokratii v Kazakhstane: Stakan napolovinu polon // URL: http://tengrinews.kz/
kazakhstan_news/nazarbaev-o-razvitii-demokratii-v-kazahstane-stakan-napolovinu-polon-232406/
27. Obukhova E., Ogorodnikov E. Vse radi rosta // Ekspert. №25 (856). 2013.
28. Obshchestvennoe mnenie — 2012. — M.: Levada-Tsentr. 2012.
29. Pobedonostsev K.P. Sochineniya. — SPb., 1996.
30. Poka Nazarbaev v otpuske, poyavilos' pis'mo o ego preemnike // URL: http://rus.azattyq.org/content/nazarbaevotpusk-
pismo-obschestvennosti/24929499.html
31. Polan'i K. Velikaya transformatsiya. Politicheskie i ekonomicheskie istoki nashego vremeni. — M., 2006.
32. Polyakov L.V. Putinskaya Rossiya: politicheskaya degradatsiya ili politicheskaya modernizatsiya?: Preprint
WP14.2007.05. — M.: Izdatel'skiy dom GU VShE, 2007.
33. Pravitel'stvo Respubliki Kazakhstan. Ofitsial'nyy sayt // URL: http://ru.government.kz/structure/government
34. Predvybornaya programma partii regionov (na russkom yazyke). 2007 g. // URL: http://www.edrus.org/content/
view/5500/47/
35. Press-sluzhby Prezidenta Respubliki Uzbekistan // URL: http://www.press-service.uz/ru/news/show/
pozdravleniya/#ru/news/show/pozdravleniya/vyistuplenie_prezidenta_islama_karimo_2/
36. Proekt «Evraziyskiy monitoring». Monitoring sotsial'nykh nastroeniy naseleniya stran postsovetskogo
prostranstva. 2004-2012 gG. Osnovnye rezul'taty. 01.03.2013.
37. Protestnye nastroeniya naseleniya: poslednie tendentsii // Ukraina: informatsionno-analiticheskiy moni-
toring. №5-6 (83-84). 2013.
38. Rech' Prezidenta Turkmenistana Gurbanguly Berdymukhamedova na sovmestnom zasedanii obshchenatsional'-
nogo dvizheniya «Galkynysh» i Demokraticheskoy partii Turkmenistana // URL: http://www.turkmenistan.
ru/?page_id=4&lang_id=ru&elem_id=10724&type=event&sort=date_desc
39. Rodionov K. Avtoritarnyy otkat na postsovetskom prostranstve // URL: http://www.corpes.ru; Dakhin V.N. Po-
liticheskie problemy postsovetskogo prostranstva // Kuda idet Rossiya?.. Sotsial'naya transformatsiya postso-
vetskogo prostranstva. — M.: Aspekt Press. 2006.
40. Rossiya i novye gosudarstva Evrazii III (XVI) / Ezhekvartal'nyy zhurnal 2012.
41. Saytova E.F. Transformatsiya politicheskikh rezhimov postsovetskikh gosudarstv: teoretiko-metodologicheskiy
aspekt // Evraziyskiy yuridicheskiy zhurnal. №9 (52). 2012.
42. Obshchee i osobennoe v politicheskom razvitii Rossii i drugikh stran SNG. (Puti rossiyskogo postkommunizma).
Ocherki / pod red. M. Lipman, A. Ryabov. Moskovskiy tsentr Karnegi. — M., 2007.
43. Sobor E. Moldova na puti k revolyutsii «pustykh kastryul'» // mezhdunarodnoe agentstvo delovykh novostey /
http://madn.com.ua
44. Suzdal'tsev A.I. Postsovetskoe prostranstvo: ukhodyashchaya real'nost' // Mir vokrug Rossii: 2017 — kontury ne-
dalekogo budushchego // URL: http://www.polit.ru
45. Surkov V.Yu. Nasha rossiyskaya model' demokratii nazyvaetsya «suverennaya demokratiya» // URL: http://web.
archive.org/web/2008043012854/http://www.edinoros.ru/news.html?id=114108
46. Tret'yakov V.M. Pochemu u nas nichego ne poluchaetsya? // Ekspert. №2 (834), №4 (836). 2013.
47. Truevtsev K.M. God 2011 — novaya demokraticheskaya volna?: preprint WP 14/2011/05 / K.M. Truevtsev: Nats. is-
sledovaniya universiteta «Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki». — M.: Izd. Dom «Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki», 2011.
48. Frenkel' A., Mal'tseva I. Rossiyskaya ekonomika v 2012-2014 godakh: tendentsii, analiz, prognoz // Ekonomi-
cheskaya strategiya. №2. 2013.
49. Furman D.E. Dvizhenie po spirali. Politicheskaya sistema Rossii v ryadu drugikh stran. M., 2010.
50. TsIK Ukrainy podvel itogi vyborov i dal novoy Rade «zelenyy svet» // URL: http://ria.ru/
world/20121111/910385932.html
51. Chan Kha Chzhun. Krizis i Evolyutsiya // Rossiya v global'noy politike. T.11.№1.2013.
52. Churov V., Borisov I., Evlanov I., Lysenko V. O soblyudenii v SShA izbiratel'nykh prav grazhdan pri provede-
nii vyborov Prezidenta SShA 6 noyabrya 2012 g. // Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn'. Fevral'. 2013.
53. Yubileynye daty 2011 goda: Research & Branding Group. 2011.
54. Yazhborovskaya I.S. Sovremennaya Tsentral'no-Vostochnaya i Yugo-Vostochnaya Evropa: problemy sotsial'nogo po-
lozheniya i sotsial'noy politiki // Slavyanovedenie. 2009. №1.
55. Yanukovich: V Ukraine slozhilas' svoeobraznaya demokratiya // Utro.ua. 11.06.2013.
References (transliteration):
1. Anrmeier H. Deutsche Reichstagstagsakten. Deutsche Reichstagstagsakten unter Maximilian I. Band 5: Reichstag
vonWorms 1495. — Vandenhoeck + Ruprecht, 1981.
2. Hoeffler A., Bates R.H., Fayad G. Income and democracy: Lipset’s Law Revisited. Working Paper №12/295. December
17, 2012.
3. Mann S.R. Chaos Theory in Strategic Thought // Parametes. Autum 1992. P. 62.
4. Agentstvo po statistike Respubliki Kazakhstan // URL: http://investfunds.kz/news/investicii-v-osnovnoj-kapital-vkazahstane-
v-yanvare-aprele-vyrosli-na-79-ia-novosti-kazahstan-33389/
5. Alieva L. Vliyanie «arabskikh» revolyutsiy na postsovetskoe prostranstvo: «Konets budet tot zhe» // URL: http://
www.regnum.ru/news
6. V Turtsii Nazarbaev predlozhil ob'edinit' 200 mln tyurkov // Kazakhinform. 13.10.2012.
7. Grozin A.V. Turkmenistan: elita, tekushchaya situatsiya i perspektivy. — M.: Institut stran SNG, 2013.
8. Dakhin V.N. Politicheskie problemy postsovetskogo prostranstva // Kuda idet Rossiya?.. Sotsial'naya transfor-
matsiya postsovetskogo prostranstva / pod obshch. red. T.I. Zaslavskoy. — M.: Aspekt Press, 2006.
9. Demidov S.M. Postsovetskiy Turkmenistan. — M., 2002.
10. Zarubezhnye seta chinovnikov zapretyat v uskorennom rezhime // Kommersant. №241 (5026). 20.10.2012.
11. Zinov'ev A.A. Zapad: izbrannye sochineniya / A.A. Zinov'ev, vstup. Stat'ya G.V. Osipova, sostavlenie Yu.N. So-
lodukhina. — M.: Astrel', 2008.
12. Iglton T. Pochemu Marks byl prav. — M., 2012.
13. Integratsionnyy barometr. EABR 2012. Evraziyskiy Bank Razvitiya. Tsentr integratsionnykh issledovaniy. —
SPb., 2012.
14. Issledovatel'skiy proekt: «Vospriyatie molodezh'yu novykh nezavisimykh gosudarstv istorii sovetskogo i
postsovetskogo periodov». Aprel'-may 2009 g. Kratkiy analiticheskiy otchet. — M., 2009.
15. Konstitutsiya Turkmenistana // URL: http://www.turkmenistan.ru/?page_id=9&lang_id=ru&elem_
id=2251&type=event&sort=date_desc
16. Kosolapov N. Proobraz postkapitalizma // Rossiya v global'noy politike. T. 11. №1. Yanvar'-fevral'. 2013.
17. Kuz'mina E.M. Politicheskoe razvitie Uzbekistana na sovremennom etape // Politicheskie protsessy v novykh nezavisimykh gosudarstvakh. Vestnik nauchnoy informatsii. — №3. — 2011.
18. Kurits S., Vorob'ev V. Karkas konstitutsii gosudarstva // Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn'. — №4. — 2013.
19. Lavrov S. Vneshnepoliticheskaya filosofiya Rossii // Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn'. — №3. — 2013.
20. Mel'vil' A.Yu. Faktory rezhimnykh transformatsiy gosudarstvennoy sostoyatel'nosti v postkommunistiche-
skikh stranakh: preprint WP14/2011/04 (ch. 1) / Mel'vil' A.Yu., Stukal D.K., Mironyuk M.G. Nats. Issledovaniya
universiteta «Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki». — M.: Izd. Dom «Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki», 2011.
21. Mel'vil' A.Yu. Faktory rezhimnykh transformatsiy i tipy gosudarstvennoy sostoyatel'nosti v postkommuni-
sticheskikh stranakh: preprint WP14/2011/04 (ch. 1)/Mel'vil' A.Yu., Stukal D.K., Mironyuk M.G. Nats. issledova-
niya universiteta «Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki». — M.: Izd. Dom «Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki», 2011.
22. Ministerstvo inostrannykh del RF. Ofitsial'nyy sayt. Perechen' osnovnykh pretenziy i rekomendatsiy mezhdu-
narodnykh organizatsiy i NPO k Latvii po pravam natsional'nykh men'shinstv // URL: http://www.mid.ru/bdomp/
Ns-dgpch.nsf/05a95604fc81125843256da400378f3b/432569ee00522d3c43256e00003017ad!OpenDocument
23. Monitoring migratsionnykh nastroeniy sootechestvennikov prozhivayushchikh za rubezhom. M.: MID RF. 2012.
24. Musaev O. Prava cheloveka v Turkmenistane — na vysote demokraticheskikh preobrazovaniy // URL: http://
niyazov.sitecity.ru/ltext_2010114405.phtml?p_ident=ltext_2010114405.p_0411151212
25. Nablyudateli sochli vybory na Ukraine neprozrachnymi // URL: http://top.rbc.ru/politics/29/10/2012/822380.shtml
26. Nazarbaev o razvitii demokratii v Kazakhstane: Stakan napolovinu polon // URL: http://tengrinews.kz/
kazakhstan_news/nazarbaev-o-razvitii-demokratii-v-kazahstane-stakan-napolovinu-polon-232406/
27. Obukhova E., Ogorodnikov E. Vse radi rosta // Ekspert. №25 (856). 2013.
28. Obshchestvennoe mnenie — 2012. — M.: Levada-Tsentr. 2012.
29. Pobedonostsev K.P. Sochineniya. — SPb., 1996.
30. Poka Nazarbaev v otpuske, poyavilos' pis'mo o ego preemnike // URL: http://rus.azattyq.org/content/nazarbaevotpusk-
pismo-obschestvennosti/24929499.html
31. Polan'i K. Velikaya transformatsiya. Politicheskie i ekonomicheskie istoki nashego vremeni. — M., 2006.
32. Polyakov L.V. Putinskaya Rossiya: politicheskaya degradatsiya ili politicheskaya modernizatsiya?: Preprint
WP14.2007.05. — M.: Izdatel'skiy dom GU VShE, 2007.
33. Pravitel'stvo Respubliki Kazakhstan. Ofitsial'nyy sayt // URL: http://ru.government.kz/structure/government
34. Predvybornaya programma partii regionov (na russkom yazyke). 2007 g. // URL: http://www.edrus.org/content/
view/5500/47/
35. Press-sluzhby Prezidenta Respubliki Uzbekistan // URL: http://www.press-service.uz/ru/news/show/
pozdravleniya/#ru/news/show/pozdravleniya/vyistuplenie_prezidenta_islama_karimo_2/
36. Proekt «Evraziyskiy monitoring». Monitoring sotsial'nykh nastroeniy naseleniya stran postsovetskogo
prostranstva. 2004-2012 gG. Osnovnye rezul'taty. 01.03.2013.
37. Protestnye nastroeniya naseleniya: poslednie tendentsii // Ukraina: informatsionno-analiticheskiy moni-
toring. №5-6 (83-84). 2013.
38. Rech' Prezidenta Turkmenistana Gurbanguly Berdymukhamedova na sovmestnom zasedanii obshchenatsional'-
nogo dvizheniya «Galkynysh» i Demokraticheskoy partii Turkmenistana // URL: http://www.turkmenistan.
ru/?page_id=4&lang_id=ru&elem_id=10724&type=event&sort=date_desc
39. Rodionov K. Avtoritarnyy otkat na postsovetskom prostranstve // URL: http://www.corpes.ru; Dakhin V.N. Po-
liticheskie problemy postsovetskogo prostranstva // Kuda idet Rossiya?.. Sotsial'naya transformatsiya postso-
vetskogo prostranstva. — M.: Aspekt Press. 2006.
40. Rossiya i novye gosudarstva Evrazii III (XVI) / Ezhekvartal'nyy zhurnal 2012.
41. Saytova E.F. Transformatsiya politicheskikh rezhimov postsovetskikh gosudarstv: teoretiko-metodologicheskiy
aspekt // Evraziyskiy yuridicheskiy zhurnal. №9 (52). 2012.
42. Obshchee i osobennoe v politicheskom razvitii Rossii i drugikh stran SNG. (Puti rossiyskogo postkommunizma).
Ocherki / pod red. M. Lipman, A. Ryabov. Moskovskiy tsentr Karnegi. — M., 2007.
43. Sobor E. Moldova na puti k revolyutsii «pustykh kastryul'» // mezhdunarodnoe agentstvo delovykh novostey /
http://madn.com.ua
44. Suzdal'tsev A.I. Postsovetskoe prostranstvo: ukhodyashchaya real'nost' // Mir vokrug Rossii: 2017 — kontury ne-
dalekogo budushchego // URL: http://www.polit.ru
45. Surkov V.Yu. Nasha rossiyskaya model' demokratii nazyvaetsya «suverennaya demokratiya» // URL: http://web.
archive.org/web/2008043012854/http://www.edinoros.ru/news.html?id=114108
46. Tret'yakov V.M. Pochemu u nas nichego ne poluchaetsya? // Ekspert. №2 (834), №4 (836). 2013.
47. Truevtsev K.M. God 2011 — novaya demokraticheskaya volna?: preprint WP 14/2011/05 / K.M. Truevtsev: Nats. is-
sledovaniya universiteta «Vysshaya shkola ekonomiki». — M.: Izd. Dom «Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki», 2011.
48. Frenkel' A., Mal'tseva I. Rossiyskaya ekonomika v 2012-2014 godakh: tendentsii, analiz, prognoz // Ekonomi-
cheskaya strategiya. №2. 2013.
49. Furman D.E. Dvizhenie po spirali. Politicheskaya sistema Rossii v ryadu drugikh stran. M., 2010.
50. TsIK Ukrainy podvel itogi vyborov i dal novoy Rade «zelenyy svet» // URL: http://ria.ru/
world/20121111/910385932.html
51. Chan Kha Chzhun. Krizis i Evolyutsiya // Rossiya v global'noy politike. T.11.№1.2013.
52. Churov V., Borisov I., Evlanov I., Lysenko V. O soblyudenii v SShA izbiratel'nykh prav grazhdan pri provede-
nii vyborov Prezidenta SShA 6 noyabrya 2012 g. // Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn'. Fevral'. 2013.
53. Yubileynye daty 2011 goda: Research & Branding Group. 2011.
54. Yazhborovskaya I.S. Sovremennaya Tsentral'no-Vostochnaya i Yugo-Vostochnaya Evropa: problemy sotsial'nogo po-
lozheniya i sotsial'noy politiki // Slavyanovedenie. 2009. №1.
55. Yanukovich: V Ukraine slozhilas' svoeobraznaya demokratiya // Utro.ua. 11.06.2013.