Правильная ссылка на статью:
Pris, I. E..
«Meaning as Use»
// Philosophy and Culture. – 2014. – № 1.
– С. 31-39.
DOI: 10.7256/1999-2793.2014.1.8969.
рубрика Западники и славянофилы сегодня
DOI: 10.7256/1999-2793.2014.1.8969
Читать статью
Аннотация: Emphasis on theory in Wittgenstein’s philosophy in terms of natural practices (language-games and
life forms) places it in close relations with Heidegger’s normative pragmatism. In particular, Heidegger focuses
on the term «use», too. However, a French philosopher Jocelyn Benoist disputes that the analogy between
Wittgenstein’s and Heidegger’s definitions of «use» has such a close nature. The author of the present article
comes back to the question about this analogy and tries to clarify whether theorization of Wittgenstein’s term
«use» is actually possible. The research was carried out based on the synthesis of hermeneutic and analytical
methods in analyzing Heidegger’s and Wittengstein’s texts from the point of view of modern analytical
philosophy and, in particular, analytical pragmatism. The author of the article tries to outline a closer relation
between Wittengstein’s and Heidegger’s philosophies within the framework of normative pragmatism and
naturalism. The author also offers analytical interpretation of certain Wittengstein’s terms such as rules, use,
family resemblance, aspect and others). The author of the article establishes that Wittengstein’s philosophy
contains implicit metaphysics that is turned into explicit metaphysics by Heidegger.
Ключевые слова: use, meaning, language-game, Dasein, Wittgenstein, Heidegger, pragmatism, naturalism, aspect, rule.
Контактная информация: Pris Igor Evgenievich, 44 287, Germany, Dortmund, Schlagbaum str, 25 (Francois-Igor PRIS).
Библиография:
Zhirar Rene. Kozel otpushcheniya / Per. s fr. Grigoriy Dashevskiy; Predisl. A. Etkinda. – SPb.: Izdatel'stvo Ivana Limbakha, 2010. 11 Lakan Zhak. Seminary. Kniga 7. Etika psikhoanaliza (1959-60) Per. s fr. Aleksandr Chernoglazov-M.: Gnozis, Logos, 2006. 12. Andrey Zorin. Pokhod v bordel' v yanvare 1800 goda / NLO № 92 2008 g. 13. Fuk Mishel'. Rozhdenie kliniki / Per. s fr. Aleksandr Tkhostov – M.: Akademicheskiy proekt, 2010. 14. Fuko Mishel'. Slova i veshchi. Arkheologiya gumanitarnykh nauk / Per. s fr. – M.: A-cad, 2004. 15. Khabermas Yurgen. Moral'noe soznanie i kommunikativnoe deystvie / Per. s nem. S . Shachin, D. Sklyadnev. Pod red. Boris Markov – M.: Nauka, 2006. 16. Burd'e P'er. Politicheskaya ontologiya Martina Khaydeggera / Per. s fr. A. Bikbov, T. Anisimova – M.: Praksis, 2003. 17. Luman Niklas. Obshchestvo obshchestva. Tom 1. Obshchestvo kak sotsial'naya sistema. Media kommunikatsii. Evolyutsiya / Per. s nem. Aleksandr Antonovskiy. Olek Nikiforov, Aleksey Glukhov – M.: Logos, 2011. 18.Kollinz Rendall. Sotsiologiya filosofiy. Global'naya teoriya intellektual'nogo izmeneniya / Per. s nem. N.S.Rozova-Novosibirsk: Sibirskiy khronograf, 2002. 19. Pavlenko A.N. Yavlyaetsya li kommunikativnaya programma obosnovaniya znaniya universal'noy? // Voprosy filosofii, 2009 god № 11 20. Kun Tomas. Struktura nauchnykh revolyutsiy / Per. s angl. I. Naletov – M.: AST, 2009.
Religioznye praktiki v sovremennoy Rossii: Sbornik statey / Pod red. K. Russele, A. Agadzhanyana. M.: Novoe izdatel'stvo, 2006. — 400 s. — (Novye materialy i issledovaniya po istorii russkoy kul'tury. Vyp. 3)
Kant, Immanuil. Sochineniya v shesti tomakh. M., “Mysl'”, 1966.-(Filosof. nasledie). T. 6.-1966.
D. Yum. Sochineiya 2 t. T. 2/ Per. s angl. S. I. Tsereteli i dr.; Vstup. st. A. F. Gryaznova; Primech. I. S. Narskogo. – 2-e izd. Dopoln. i ispr. – M.: Mysl', 1996.
Kozhev Aleksandr. Ateizm i drugie raboty / Per. s fr. A.M. Rutkevicha i dr. – M.: Praksis, 2006.
Kozhev Aleksandr. Vvedenie v chtenie Gegelya i drugie raboty / Per. s fr. – M.: Nauka, 2003.
Safranski Ryudiger. Martin Khaydegger: germanskiy master i ego vremya germanskiy master i ego vremya / Per. s nem. – M.: Molodaya Gvardiya, 2005.
Le College de Sociologie: 1937-1939 / Sost. Deni Ol'e. Per. s fr. Yu. Bessonova – M.: Nauka. 2004.
Tanatografiya Erosa. Zhorzh Batay i frantsuzskaya mysl' serediny XX veka / Per. s fr. – M.: Mifril, 1994.
Zhirar Rene. Nasilie i svyashchennoe / Per. s fr. Grigoriy Dashevskiy – M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 2000.
References (transliteration):
Zhirar Rene. Kozel otpushcheniya / Per. s fr. Grigoriy Dashevskiy; Predisl. A. Etkinda. – SPb.: Izdatel'stvo Ivana Limbakha, 2010. 11 Lakan Zhak. Seminary. Kniga 7. Etika psikhoanaliza (1959-60) Per. s fr. Aleksandr Chernoglazov-M.: Gnozis, Logos, 2006. 12. Andrey Zorin. Pokhod v bordel' v yanvare 1800 goda / NLO № 92 2008 g. 13. Fuk Mishel'. Rozhdenie kliniki / Per. s fr. Aleksandr Tkhostov – M.: Akademicheskiy proekt, 2010. 14. Fuko Mishel'. Slova i veshchi. Arkheologiya gumanitarnykh nauk / Per. s fr. – M.: A-cad, 2004. 15. Khabermas Yurgen. Moral'noe soznanie i kommunikativnoe deystvie / Per. s nem. S . Shachin, D. Sklyadnev. Pod red. Boris Markov – M.: Nauka, 2006. 16. Burd'e P'er. Politicheskaya ontologiya Martina Khaydeggera / Per. s fr. A. Bikbov, T. Anisimova – M.: Praksis, 2003. 17. Luman Niklas. Obshchestvo obshchestva. Tom 1. Obshchestvo kak sotsial'naya sistema. Media kommunikatsii. Evolyutsiya / Per. s nem. Aleksandr Antonovskiy. Olek Nikiforov, Aleksey Glukhov – M.: Logos, 2011. 18.Kollinz Rendall. Sotsiologiya filosofiy. Global'naya teoriya intellektual'nogo izmeneniya / Per. s nem. N.S.Rozova-Novosibirsk: Sibirskiy khronograf, 2002. 19. Pavlenko A.N. Yavlyaetsya li kommunikativnaya programma obosnovaniya znaniya universal'noy? // Voprosy filosofii, 2009 god № 11 20. Kun Tomas. Struktura nauchnykh revolyutsiy / Per. s angl. I. Naletov – M.: AST, 2009.
Religioznye praktiki v sovremennoy Rossii: Sbornik statey / Pod red. K. Russele, A. Agadzhanyana. M.: Novoe izdatel'stvo, 2006. — 400 s. — (Novye materialy i issledovaniya po istorii russkoy kul'tury. Vyp. 3)
Kant, Immanuil. Sochineniya v shesti tomakh. M., “Mysl'”, 1966.-(Filosof. nasledie). T. 6.-1966.
D. Yum. Sochineiya 2 t. T. 2/ Per. s angl. S. I. Tsereteli i dr.; Vstup. st. A. F. Gryaznova; Primech. I. S. Narskogo. – 2-e izd. Dopoln. i ispr. – M.: Mysl', 1996.
Kozhev Aleksandr. Ateizm i drugie raboty / Per. s fr. A.M. Rutkevicha i dr. – M.: Praksis, 2006.
Kozhev Aleksandr. Vvedenie v chtenie Gegelya i drugie raboty / Per. s fr. – M.: Nauka, 2003.
Safranski Ryudiger. Martin Khaydegger: germanskiy master i ego vremya germanskiy master i ego vremya / Per. s nem. – M.: Molodaya Gvardiya, 2005.
Le College de Sociologie: 1937-1939 / Sost. Deni Ol'e. Per. s fr. Yu. Bessonova – M.: Nauka. 2004.
Tanatografiya Erosa. Zhorzh Batay i frantsuzskaya mysl' serediny XX veka / Per. s fr. – M.: Mifril, 1994.
Zhirar Rene. Nasilie i svyashchennoe / Per. s fr. Grigoriy Dashevskiy – M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 2000.